Puffy vs Nectar Mattress Review

Written by: Alex Savy
Read 6 minLast updated August 25, 2020

These two brands are among the top mattresses on the market.

And there are many reasons for such popularity.

But when standing side by side, what makes the Puffy and the Nectar different from each other? And which one would be more suitable for you? That’s what I want to figure out in my Puffy vs Nectar review today.

Main Differences Between the Puffy and the Nectar Mattresses

  • The Puffy and the Nectar can be characterized as Medium-Firm mattresses (6.5 on the firmness scale).
  • The Nectar uses a breathable Tencel cover while the Puffy has a stretchy polyester cover, which isn’t the most breathable fabric out there. However, the Puffy’s cover is stain-resistant.
  • The Nectar mattress is around $150 cheaper than the Puffy.
  • Puffy offers a shorter sleep trial than Nectar (101 nights vs 365 nights).
  • While both mattresses are quite supportive, the Nectar and Puffy can accommodate larger sleepers (above 230 pounds) better.

Puffy vs Nectar Cover Comparison

Let’s start our Puffy vs Nectar review with the cover – the mattress part that’s the closest to your body during sleep.

The Puffy uses polyester for the cover, which is quite thin and smooth to the touch. It is stain-resistant, which is one of the things the Puffy is famous for. Just like in many other beds in a box, Puffy’s cover is removable (zippered) and machine washable. It has tiny pores that allow for better air circulation and make the polyester fabric a bit more breathable.

Moving on to the Nectar, which uses Tencel for its cover. Tencel is a natural fabric made of wood pulp into cellulose fibers. This makes Nectar’s cover soft to the touch and breathable. The fabric effectively wicks moisture away and allows for unobstructed airflow, which may have a cooling effect. There’s also a thin layer of memory foam quilted into the cover for extra cushioning.

Puffy vs Nectar Construction

Another important part of my Puffy vs Nectar review is the construction of both mattresses. The layers used in each of them can determine the overall feel and the comfort levels of these beds. Now, the Puffy has 3 individual layers. The base layer is the 6-inch Firm Core Support, made of polyfoam that offers resilient, sturdy support. The next layer is the 2-inch Climate Comfort. It’s made of polyfoam as well (infused with gel) and serves as the transition layer. It also works to resist temperature fluctuations and supports the temperature-neutral feel of the mattress. Finally, the top 2-inch Cooling Cloud layer uses gel-infused memory foam for an extra cooling effect and offers a gentle hug.

Check current price of Puffy on Puffy.com

Moving on to the Nectar, which is also an all-foam mattress. The base layer is high-density polyfoam for sturdy support (6 inches tall). Then we have the 1-inch Hi Core memory foam layer for a smoother transition and pressure relief. This layer responds to pressure a bit faster than regular foam and prevents that quicksand feeling. The comfort layer is gel memory foam (3 inches thick), which offers a generous hug and immediate pressure relief. Finally, there’s an extra inch of memory foam quilted into the cover. It makes the surface feel like a Euro-top and gives the Nectar a luxurious finish.

Check current price of Nectar on NectarSleep.com

Puffy vs Nectar Firmness

As the Puffy is an all-foam mattress, it doesn’t offer much bounce. On the contrary, this model responds slowly to pressure and has a hugging feel. It is a Medium bed that rates around 5 on the firmness scale, with 10 being the firmest.

Moving on to the Nectar. It has a slightly firmer feel and rates 6.5 on the firmness scale. The Nectar has that classic memory foam feel with enough cushioning but doesn’t make sleepers feel trapped due to its firmer base.

Puffy vs Nectar Edge Support

Edge support is another aspect I want to address in my Puffy vs Nectar review as it can be crucial for couples or sleepers who tend to roll onto the bed edge during the night.

As foam mattresses often lack edge support, the Puffy was not an exception. There’s no reinforcement around the perimeter, so the foam around the edges easily collapses under the weight. While you aren’t likely to fall down when lying near the edge, you might not feel that comfortable or supported properly.

The same goes for the Nectar. This all-foam mattress offers mediocre edge support. Even though this model is a bit firmer, the foam around the edges is still rather weak and collapses easily if you sit on the edge. You can still sleep close to the edges, but chances are you won’t experience enough of the needed support.

If you require a bed with strong edges, it might be a good idea to check hybrid mattresses that have reinforced edges and a sturdy coil base that provides consistent support all across the surface.

Puffy vs Nectar Motion Transfer

When looking at the Nectar vs Puffy comparison, it’s a very close call in terms of motion transfer

The Puffy has a softer feel and offers almost no bounce at all. It absorbs shock from movement easily, which means you will not disturb your partner even if you tend to toss and turn during the night.

As for the Nectar, it also does an excellent job of reducing motion transfer. The foam layers in the construction make this mattress less resilient, so your partner is likely to feel nothing when you move or even get out of bed.

Puffy vs Nectar – How They Feel for Different Types of Sleepers

Starting with the Puffy, it is safe to say that this mattress would be the most suited for average and lightweight side sleepers. As this is a softer model, it would allow for enough sinkage to accommodate your shoulders and hips. However, it’s still supportive enough to keep the spine neutrally aligned. If you are lightweight (less than 130 pounds), you may also enjoy the Puffy when sleeping on your back. For larger individuals, the Puffy may be too soft, even if you sleep on one side. The same rule applies to strict stomach sleepers, as this mattress is too plush for them.

Check current price of Puffy on Puffy.com

As for the Nectar, it can be suited for average or overweight side sleepers the best. It would also work for back sleepers of all weight categories. As for strict stomach sleepers, the Nectar is recommended for average users between 130 and 230 pounds. It would be too stiff for lightweight stomach sleepers and not supportive enough for larger individuals that prefer sleeping on their stomach.

Check current price of Nectar on NectarSleep.com

Side sleepersAverage weight – great
Petite – good
Overweight – good
Average weight – great
Petite – not recommended
Overweight – great
Back sleepersAverage weight – great
Petite – great
Overweight – good
Average weight – good
Petite – good
Overweight – good
Stomach sleepersAverage weight – good
Petite – good
Overweight – not recommended
Average weight – good
Petite – not recommended
Overweight – not recommended

Other Important Information

Other aspects you may want to consider include the sleep trial. As some mattresses have a break-in period, testing them at home and having a chance to return your bed is a great bonus. The Puffy comes with a 101-night trial, while the Nectar allows for a 365-night in-home test.

Both mattresses come with a lifetime warranty, although the Nectar’s one is called “Forever warranty” and it covers a bit more than the Puffy’s warranty does.

The Nectar usually comes with 2 pillows for free, so it would be a good option for value seekers. Both Puffy and Nectar offer financing to their customers, so you can pay for your new mattress in parts.

The Puffy is manufactured in the USA. The mattress foam is CertiPUR-US certified, which means it doesn’t contain any harmful chemicals.

As for Nectar, the company has manufacturing spots in Vietnam, China, Malaysia, Mexico, and the USA. However, the Nectar is CertiPUR-US certified as well, so you don’t have to worry about the dangerous components inside the mattress.

Bottom Line

To sum up, the Puffy and the Nectar do have a lot in common, but some of their characteristics can be real deal-breakers. While the Nectar offers a longer trial and a slightly better warranty coverage, the Puffy has a softer feel and might work better for more lightweight individuals.

CoverPolyesterTencel + cotton
Construction3 layers of foam3 layers of foam + quilted foam cover
FirmnessMedium-Firm (6.5)Medium-Firm (6.5)
Edge supportMediocreMediocre
Motion transferGoodExcellent
Trial101 nights365 nights
Price$850 (Queen, currently on sale)$699 (Queen, currently on sale)
WarrantyLifetimeForever warranty

Additional resources:

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission with no extra cost to you. Learn More

Leave a comment