Clicky

How to Find the Most Durable Mattress: Buyer’s Guide and Top 5 Recommendations

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission with no extra cost to you. Learn More

Written by: Alex Savy
Read 31 minLast updated on September 17, 2022

When a mattress betrays you and loses its properties too fast, it’s hard not to be disappointed.  

However, there’s a chance to avoid that in the future.

Take a look at the list of the most durable mattresses and learn how to find the best option for yourself. Let’s cut right to the chase!

A Quick Preview

Puffy
Best Overall

Puffy
Check Current Price
Read more about this mattress
Saatva
Most Durable for Back Sleepers

Saatva Classic Mattress
Check Current Price
Read more about this mattress
Eight Sleep Pod 3
Best Cooling Mattress

Eight Sleep Pod 3
Check Current Price
Read more about this mattress
Puffy
Best Affordable Luxury

Cocoon Chill Mattress
Check Current Price
Read more about this mattress
Nectar Premier
Most Durable for Side Sleepers

Nectar Premier
Check Current Price
Read more about this mattress
Winkbeds
Best for Couples

WinkBeds
Check Current Price
Read more about this mattress
Amerisleep AS3
Best Memory Foam Mattress

Amerisleep AS3
Check Current Price
Read more about this mattress

Our Reviews of 7 Most Durable Mattresses

Best Overall - Editor’s Choice — Puffy 

Puffy Mattress Review

Highlights 

  • gel-infused foam for cool pressure relief;
  • removable cover for easy maintenance;
  • medium feel, would work for a wide range of sleepers;
  • uses high-density foams for long-term performance;
  • close conforming for proper weight distribution.

I would like to start the list of the most durable mattresses with this hybrid by Puffy. While this mattress is most notable for its versatility, its medium firmness build provides the right amount of cushion and support for the side, which in turn aids in less tense shoulders and hips. The support which is six inches of firm mattress core ensures users enjoy this mattress for a long time. 

This model has a high-density Firm Support Core that is meant to maintain stable performance and combat premature sagging. Additionally, the Puffy delivers high comfort levels for a rather reasonable price. Plus, this mattress has a medium feel that would work for a wide variety of sleepers.

Read our full Puffy mattress review for more information.
Puffy Mattress Topper - Cover-min
Puffy Mattress On Bed Frame

Most Durable Mattress for Back Sleepers — Saatva Classic Mattress 

Saatva Classic Mattress

 

Click the button below to check current price 

Check Current Price Get Up to $450 OFF

Highlights 

  • tempered steel coils for increased lifespan;
  • patented spinal technology to offer proper back support;
  • multiple comfort variations to accommodate more types of sleepers.

Next up is the Saatva Classic Mattress which is the most durable mattress for people who need back support. The combination of tempered steel coils and a high-density foam reinforcement around the perimeter makes this model feel super-sturdy and kind of rigid. Such a construction means that the Saatva was built to last and will likely serve you for years. Even the cover fabric is of top quality. So, if you are looking for a long-term investment, this mattress might be your choice. And don’t worry: despite its durable construction, the Saatva is super comfy. 

Best Cooling Mattress — Eight Sleep Pod 3

Eight Sleep Pod 3

Click the button below to check current price 

Check Current Price Read our detailed review

Highlights:

  • Advanced cooling technology for a better night’s sleep.
  • A durable 4-inch foam base ensures the mattress will support a sleeper’s weight for a long time.
  • Conforming foam ensures the body and spine are supported for pressure relief.

The Eight Sleep Pod 3 is the best cooling and durable mattress due to its Active Grid, a 1-inch layer under a highly durable cover that senses and regulates a sleeper’s temperature. It has the ability to cool a sleeper down to 55 F, which is great for those who have problems sleeping hot and also want a mattress that will last them a long time.

On top of the cover being made of durable material to enhance longevity, the core base of the mattress is made of 4 inches of premium foam designed to support a sleeper’s weight for a long time. That means you don’t have to worry about this mattress sagging on you while you’re using their Sleep Track technology for better sleep every night.

Best Affordable Luxury Mattress – Cocoon Chill Mattress

Cocoon Chill Hybrid

Click the button below to check current price 

Check Current Price Read our detailed review

Highlights

  • Foam + springs structure for a blend of comfort, support, and durability.
  • Innersprings and premium cover infused with phase change material for ventilation and body cooling.
  • Innersprings make it responsive; also encased in fabric material for less motion transfer and squeaking noise.

Memory foam fans who don't want an inexpensive mattress but need a firmer and durable one will find everything they need in this Cocoon Chill Hybrid Mattress. Made by Sealy, it's a luxury but an affordable mattress that is cheaper than memory foam models from Saatva, Casper, Leesa, and Purple.  

What makes this a durable mattress are the springs in the mattress's core. It gives the mattress a bounciness, edge support, and resistance not found in memory foam models. The core springs make the mattress a bit firmer. Hence, I think it's a great option for side and back sleepers and those with a higher BMI.

Most Durable for Side Sleepers — Nectar Premier 

Nectar Memory Foam Mattress

Click the button below to check current price 

Check Current Price Read our detailed review

Highlights

  • medium feel to ensure a balanced combination of support and cradling;
  • cooling foam for improved thermoregulation regardless of the season;
  • extra-dense support foam to deliver reliable, long-lasting performance.

Looking for the most durable mattress for side sleeping that can cushion your contours during sleep? Then the Nectar might be your perfect match! This mattress adapts to the sleeper’s shape and makes sure there’s no tension build-up in the body. Despite its hugging feel, the Nectar itself feels robust and sturdy. It’s made using premium materials and will likely serve you for years to come.

Most Durable Mattress for Couples — Winkbeds

Winkbed-P1077807

Click the button below to check current price

Check Current Price FATHER'S DAY SALE! SAVE $300 ON YOUR MATTRESS!

Highlights

  • DuraTech system with wear-resistant coils for durable support;
  • Sag-resistant high-density foam for extra longevity;
  • It has the right firmness to support back and stomach sleepers;
  • Eurotop design for extra cushioning;
  • Strong edges for more sleeping space.

Winkbeds is a hybrid mattress with exceptional edge support obtained from rows of pocketed coils that act as a firm core. It is well known that a strong edge support feature is an important criteria for mattress longevity and that extra space for couples. It gets better: the Winkbed is available in 4 firmness variations, which means there’s a suitable option for any user.

Read our full Winkbed mattress review for more information.

Winkbeds-P1077851
Winkbed Mattress On a Bed Frame

Best Memory Foam Mattress — Amerisleep AS3

AS5 by Amerisleep

Click the button below to check current price 

Check Current Price

Highlights

  • Plant-based Bio-Pur memory foam is cool to the touch for easier sleep.
  • Perfect balanced support and conforming memory foam make this mattress ideal for combination sleepers.
  • Firm, reinforced edge support makes the surface area more supported and durable.

The Amerisleep AS3 is one of the most durable memory foam mattresses due to its unique Bio-Pur material, which not only is environmentally friendly, but it’s also more breathable with its open-cell design, helping sleepers stay cool all throughout the night while enjoying this mattress’ cushioning, slow-adapting foam. The base of this mattress also has a transitional foam layer designed to increase its durability, meaning sleepers will get to enjoy their AS3 longer.

On top of this, I also like how the AS3 comes with a breathable, moisture-wicking cover designed to prevent overheating. This is great for hot summer nights when you need a little extra breathability to keep your sleep undisturbed and peaceful.

Which Mattress Type Is the Most Durable?

When trying to find the most durable mattress, you may start wondering: Which type would serve me the longest?  Now, while many factors can affect the lifespan of your mattress, it’s useful to know which materials tend to be more long-lasting than the others. So, here are the main mattress types you can come across:

  • Memory foam. With time, memory foam mattresses can develop sags or body impressions and lose their supportive abilities. Typically, foam mattresses can last for around 10 years with the right care (1). Of course, there are higher quality mattresses that won’t sag and can last longer than that (for around 15 years), but there aren’t too many of them.

Memory foam mattresses have above average durability. They are especially more durable than most other foam mattresses because they have a higher density. To get the best durable memory foam mattress, pay attention to the pound per cubic feet rating. A rating of 3.4 - 4 lbs/ft³ will prove very durable for the average sleeper, while heavier sleepers can opt for 5 lbs/ft³ rated mattresses.

  • Latex. Latex models are considered to be the longest-lasting mattresses. On average, such beds can last for around 15 years without losing their properties (2), which explains their higher price point. However, it’s important to pay attention to the latex type. While natural latex is extremely durable, synthetic variations of this material usually have a shorter lifespan.

For the most durability, opt for a latex mattress made from organic/natural latex. They usually come in Talalay or Dunlop latex, and would typically cost more than the synthetic types. Although, there are some other latex mattress options that are a hybrid of natural and synthetic latex. These won’t last as much as a completely organic latex mattress, but also won’t cost as much.

  • Hybrid. Hybrid mattresses usually combine an innerspring support system with foam or latex comfort layers. Of course, some of the best hybrid mattresses use thicker coils and denser comfort materials to ensure a prolonged lifespan. However, most hybrid beds last for no more than 10 years on average.

Hybrid mattresses offer a wide variety of options. You need to pay attention to the type of foam used and the layers of the mattress. Also important is the foam density. The foam density often influences the overall durability and comfort you’ll get from the bed over the years.

  • Innerspring. Spring beds use a system of coils for support and tend to have a rather limited lifespan. Because metal coils can lose their elasticity quite soon, innerspring mattresses typically last for around 6 years (3) (maybe a couple of years more if they don’t support that much weight). Some models can serve for up to 10 years if they have a flippable design and allow users to alternate between the sides to avoid applying pressure to the same spots all the time.

Apart from the spring section of these mattresses, you should pay attention to the foam cover as well. Innerspring mattresses come in Eurotop and pillow top types, these differ in comfortability, but Eurotop covers are often more durable.

  • Air mattress. Airbeds are a great option for camping or occasional guests. Because these mattresses aren’t typically used very frequently, they can last for around 5-6 years on average despite being prone to puncture.

As a general note, you can expect an air mattress to last based on how well it is used. To maximize the durability of an air mattress, it has to be packed well and stored after use away from humid spots and extreme conditions. Also, avoid using heated blankets on them, and pay attention to leaks for immediate fixing as well.

Which Mattress Type Is the Most Durable

Source: https://wastersblog.com/97584/mattress-lifespan/

How to Find a Durable Mattress

There must be a secret behind good long-lasting mattresses, right? Well, you could say so.  Some factors can affect mattress’s durability and make it more reliable in use, but they depend on each material. So, if you want to find the longest-lasting mattress that would serve you loyally for years, pay attention to its construction.

If we are talking about memory foam, density plays a huge role here. Low-density models tend to develop sags, lumps, and body impressions quite fast (sometimes within the first couple of years). The high-density foam serves longer and doesn’t lose its supportive properties that fast.

So, when shopping for a new mattress, check the numbers. Lower-density foam is rated around 3 pounds per cubic foot and less (3 lbs/ft3 or less). Such foam typically has a plushier feel and works better for lightweight sleepers. Medium density is around 4-5 lbs/ft3. Mattresses that use this foam density usually work for average sleepers, often have a medium feel, and might be suited for different sleeping positions. Denser foams are the ones rated 5 lbs/ft3 and up. Such foams do not necessarily have a stiffer feel but can offer decent support levels, even for heavier individuals. And of course, dense foams usually make longer-lasting mattresses. How to Find a Durable Mattress

Source: https://www.comfortoption.com/mattress-engineering

Now, when it comes to latex, its density is not that vital. Of course, just like foam, denser latex is more durable than its low-density variations. But because the material shows excellent results in terms of durability, even a low-density latex mattress would typically last longer than any other type. Moving on to hybrid mattresses.

Firstly, look at the comfort layers and what material is used for them. If it’s latex, you shouldn’t worry. If it’s foam, it shouldn’t be low-density. Now, as for the innerspring support system, you need to pay attention to the coil gauge. Usually rated from 12 to 18, the gauge signifies the thickness of the coils. The thickest ones are rated 12, and the thinnest ones are rated 18. Of course, for increased durability, you want thicker coils. You might also choose those if you are a heavier user who requires more reliable support. It’s also better to choose wrapped (pocketed) coils over the rest of the types (offset, Bonnell, etc.), as they tend to be more durable (and much quieter).

Another factor you might want to account for is the warranty. A longer warranty period might be a good indication that the mattress you are considering uses quality materials. Just like that, you should be careful with companies that offer short warranties. It might mean that the manufacturer isn’t sure of their product’s quality (leaving you unprotected as a customer in case your new mattress loses its properties (4) faster than it should).

Other Factors to Consider When Shopping for the Most Durable Mattress

When your old mattress starts to show signs of deterioration and it’s time to buy a new one, you probably want your next bed to be longer-lasting.

But here’s the deal:

Durability is not the only crucial factor you need to account for. There are many characteristics that can either make your new mattress work with you or turn against you.

So, when searching for your best durable mattress, try not to neglect the following factors: 

  • Firmness. If you want to find the most comfortable mattress, it has to correspond to your favorite sleeping position. Let me explain: each sleeping position requires a different level of sinkage and support. For instance, side sleepers need a generous amount of cushioning for their shoulders and hips, therefore they are recommended to choose softer mattresses (rated around 4 on the firmness scale, with 10 being the stiffest). People who prefer sleeping on their back don’t need that much of a hug, but moderate sinkage is desirable to cradle the hips and buttocks. That’s why back sleepers are advised to pick medium mattresses (rated around 5-6). As for stomach sleepers, their body has to remain in a relatively straight line during the night, so they require stable, reliable support. In this case, a firmer mattress would be the most optimal option (rated around 7-8 on the firmness scale).
  • Type. You already know which mattress type is the most durable one. But not any longest-lasting mattress would work for you, as each type has a specific set of characteristics. For example, memory foam is very hugging and molds to the sleeper’s body. It can sometimes feel like a bear hug, which some users enjoy, and others associate with feeling trapped. Latex mattresses are quite bouncy but can also deliver close conforming. They are good for pressure relief but don’t have that quicksand feeling. Hybrid beds usually have a balanced feel with a decent amount of bouncy support and cradling. Depending on the comfort layers and their thickness, a hybrid mattress can feel more or less hugging. As for innerspring beds, they are very bouncy and responsive. They usually deliver uniform support all across the surface but aren’t that great for pressure relief.
  • Price. Consider your budget and how much you are willing to spend. Remember that a cheap price does not necessarily mean a short lifespan. But even if you find the best cheap mattress, don’t expect it to serve you for as long as pricier models. Usually, cheaper mattresses use lower-quality materials that have a shorter lifespan. So it’s better to be careful with models that cost less than $500 (for a Queen).
  • Warranty. As I’ve mentioned before, a prolonged warranty period can indicate that the manufacturer is sure of their product’s quality. Which means they have probably used durable materials that would last you longer.
  • Your weight. When searching for a long-lasting mattress, you should factor your weight in. You see, heavier users (over 230 pounds) need firmer support to maintain proper spinal alignment during sleep. That’s why they should choose slightly firmer mattresses for each sleeping position. As for lightweight sleepers, some mattresses might be too hard on their joints and protruding body parts. Therefore, petite individuals are advised to pick softer mattresses that offer more cushioning.
  • Your partner. If you share your bed with a loved one, this would mean more pressure on your mattress (which can also affect its lifespan). A bigger combined weight means that you might want to pick a slightly firmer mattress. Another aspect related to partnered sleep is motion isolation. If one of you is a restless sleeper who might disturb their partner during the night, it’s better to pick a good motion-absorbing mattress. Memory foam shows excellent results in this case, but you can also consider a hybrid mattress with extra-thick foam comfort layers. 

Tips to making a durable mattress last longer


After considering all appropriate factors in choosing a durable mattress, how long it would last and how well it would be enjoyed is dependent on its usage. The best way to ensure that a mattress is durable is to take good care of it. Here are a few things you can do to improve the mattress lifespan.

  • Get a good bed frame. A solid bed frame can add a couple years to the lifespan of your bed. The support the frame provides helps to keep a mattress in good shape. It is significantly different from placing your bed directly on a hard surface like marble or hardwood. Hard surfaces would weaken the integrity of a mattress component faster. Using a bed frame also means you can flip your mattress every few months which would also help you enjoy your mattress longer.

  • Consider using a quality topper. A quality mattress topper would not add an extra layer of thickness to your bed but also can improve the comfort. Top mattress toppers made from gel-infused memory foam or other high-density materials are great options to improve the durability of a mattress. Though these would come at an extra cost, they are often worth the spend. But if your mattress is already sagging or shows clear indentation, a topper would not prove effective, you can consider any of the durable mattresses we have recommended.

  • Use a mattress protector. A mattress protector would help keep your bed in proper shape. Especially for foam mattresses, a mattress protector would keep it in a compact shape which is better for the overall durability of the bed. This is also important to prevent infestation of insects like bed bugs and mites which can make sleep very uncomfortable.

  • Keep your mattress clean. Any mattress can easily get worn out when not well maintained. One of the basic ways to maintain a mattress is to keep it clean. For mattresses containing layers with memory foam, getting substances like water on it will damage the material and make it less durable. And if you’re a pet person, you might want to consider getting your fluffy pals a bed of their own. Pets can get urine on a mattress or scratch the surface which could also damage the material and affect the durability.

F.A.Q.

How often do I need to replace my mattress?

Ideally, a mattress should be replaced every 6-8 years if you want to maintain the highest comfort levels. But the actual term would depend on your mattress type. Latex mattresses are the most durable ones, memory foam can serve for around 10 years, and hybrid and innerspring mattresses typically serve for around 6-7 years.

Can I make my mattress last longer?

Yes. If your mattress allows for it, you can flip it regularly to avoid body impressions. Rotating the mattress might also help. Using a mattress protector can help you prevent any spills and other accidents and keep your bed clean and fresh. Also, make sure that your mattress is supported properly and that it is standing on a reliable bed frame (old, weak, and worn-out slats can make your mattress wear out faster).

Are durable mattresses more expensive?

Usually, yes. A higher price point can oftentimes means top-quality and longer-lasting materials. However, it does not necessarily mean that ALL expensive mattresses are durable. Sometimes manufacturers set a higher price because of the famous brand name or some bells and whistles the mattress comes with.

Will a firm mattress last longer?

Generally, yes. Firmer mattresses typically use denser foams/latex or thicker coils (thus, more durable materials) to achieve a stiffer feel.

How do you know when to replace a mattress?

You should look for such signs as sags, lumps, or indentations. If your mattress feels much softer than before, you should probably replace it. If you wake up with a sore back or stiff shoulders, this can also be a bad sign. If your allergies are acting up, this can mean that your old mattress contains mold or bed bugs.

Wrapping Up

Now when you know how to find the best durable mattress, all you have to do is make the final choice. Remember that a good mattress should not only serve you for a long time but also offer the proper support level. Pay attention to the firmness and the materials used when shopping. And don’t forget to check the warranty, as it can be an indication of the product’s quality. 

If you still can’t make up your mind, allow me to recommend my personal favorite – the Puffy Mattress. This mattress has a lot to offer, especially for side sleepers. Such a mattress is a rare gem as it is made of a memory foam mattress that will provide pressure relief. 

What makes it a durable model is that it's made of high-density memory foam for better support and long-term performance that's not expected from a foam mattress. And here's the best part; it's infused with gel, which eliminates the warmness characteristics memory foam materials impose on sleepers.

Are you ready to get a new mattress? Which model impressed you the most? Share your thoughts in the comments!

 

References

  1. Adrienne Santos-Longhurst (June 12, 2020). How Often Should You Replace Your Mattress? Retrieved from https://www.healthline.com/health/when-to-change-mattress
  2. Abe Abbas (May 08, 2020). When to Replace a Mattress. Retrieved from https://www.thespruce.com/how-often-to-replace-mattresses-1391234
  3. Jenni Gritters (August 22, 2020). Your mattress should last 7-10 years — here's how to tell when you need a replacement. Retrieved from https://www.insider.com/how-long-does-a-mattress-last
  4. Amanda Capritto (October 27, 2019). 9 signs it's time to replace your mattress. Retrieved from https://www.cnet.com/health/how-long-does-a-mattress-last/

Subscribe to get updates and new deals!

Zero spam. Unsubscribe at any time

Our research

27

Mattresses Considered

112

Hours of Research

2

Sleep Experts Consulted

Leave a comment