Top 6 Most Comfortable Mattresses in 2023

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission with no extra cost to you. Learn More

Written by: Alex Savy
Read 40 minLast updated on April 10, 2023

If you're like most people, you spend one-third of your life asleep. And while the sleep you get must be comfortable, it's also important that your mattress is.

We've done the hard work for you and found 6 of the most comfortable mattresses to buy. 

Even if you're on a tight budget, there are several high-quality mattresses that won't break the bank.

We've thoroughly tested industry bestsellers and summed up our experience. Hopefully, this will help you find the model that appeals to you.

 Let's get started.

A Quick Preview

Puffy Mattress
Best Overall - Editor’s Pick

Puffy Mattress
Check Current Price
Read more about this mattress
Runner Up

Check Current Price
Read more about this mattress
Amerisleep AS3

Amerisleep AS3
Check Current Price
Read more about this mattress
Best for Heavier Sleepers

Check Current Price
Read more about this mattress
Best for Side Sleepers

Check Current Price
Read more about this mattress
Brooklyn Signature Hybrid
Best for People with Back Pain

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid
Check Current Price
Read more about this mattress

Our Reviews of the Top 6 Most Comfortable Mattresses

Best Overall - Editor’s Pick — Puffy Mattress

Puffy Mattress


  • 4 inches of pressure-relieving memory foam help ease muscle tension for buttery, cradling comfort.
  • Slow-adaptive Cooling Cloud foam reacts to the body slowly, giving a comfortable body-hugging feel.
  • The cover is removable and washable, which can help keep your sleeping space clean.

The Puffy is my editor’s pick for the most comfortable mattress for its generously thick comfort layers, slow-adaptive Cooling Cloud foam layer, and removable cover. I reviewed the Puffy and found its comfort layers to allow for plenty of sinkage, measuring 2.5 inches. Puffy’s sinkage was more than the AS3 (also an all-foam mattress) by 12.8%, making it the better option for deep, comfortable cradling. Additionally, Puffy’s Cooling Cloud foam layer adapts to the body slowly, measuring 1.7 seconds to bounce back from compressions fully. This slow response time is well-balanced, conforming to your body for comfort while also being fast enough not to make you feel too restricted while changing sleeping positions.

Puffy’s stain-resistant cover was another feature I reviewed. I found it easy to remove (via zippers) for machine-washing, meaning you don’t have to worry about bringing your favorite drinks to bed or staying up for a midnight snack.

What I Don’t Like About This Mattress

One feature I don’t like about the Puffy is that it may not be supportive enough for heavier sleepers over 230 pounds due to its soft layers.

puffy mattress firmness
Puffy Mattress On Bed Frame

Read our full Puffy mattress review for more information.

Runner Up — Saatva 

Saatva Classic Mattress

Click the button below to check current price

Check Current PriceGet 12% OFF


  • three firmness options to satisfy different types of sleepers;
  • edge reinforcement to offer extra sleeping space;
  • pocketed comfort coils for targeted support.

Saatva ranks high on a list of the most comfortable mattresses as the hybrid innerspring mattress is designed for both comfort and functionality. With its dual coil design, this model provides reliable and durable body support for proper spinal alignment during sleep. Extra cushioning is also available with its thick pillow top layer making the Saatva feel comfortable and pretty luxurious. Finally, various sleeper types would also find this model convenient as it has three firmness options designed to meet the different sleeping needs.

All things considered, the Saatva is certainly worth your attention. It’s a sturdy mattress that does not sacrifice comfort for its reliable construction.

Read our full Saatva mattress review for more information.

Best Memory Foam Option — Amerisleep AS3

Amerisleep AS3

Click the button below to check current price 

Check Current Price


  • plant-based Bio-Pur foam to create a safer sleep environment (more resistant to dust mites and mold);
  • open-cell design for cooler sleep without giving up generous cradling; 
  • HIVE transition layer for targeted support.

Memory foam mattresses are known for their pain relief and motion isolation features, and if you’re a fan of memory foam mattresses, you might want to check out this option. This all-foam model is built to accommodate various sleepers and body types with its unique features. One of such is its breathable ventilated foam design fitted with an open cell transition layer which supports thermoregulation during sleep, especially at night, making it quite beneficial to hot sleepers. Also, it is equipped with pocketed coils which provide reliable support and excellent pressure relief.

You might also appreciate the fact that the AS3 has a zoned transition layer for unparalleled support. It has separate zones for different body parts (5 in total), which respond to pressure differently and thus, help keep the spine aligned and healthy. Let me just tell you this: after a long day in front of the computer, my stiff and sore back found almost instant relief when I laid down on this mattress. That’s the spinal alignment in action, so to say.

Side Sleeping on Amerisleep Mattress
AS5 by Amerisleep

Read our full Amerisleep AS3 mattress review for more information.

Best for Heavier Sleepers — Winkbed


Click the button below to check current price Check Current PriceGet $300 OFF


  • Four firmness options, suitable for all body types and sleeping positions;
  • zoned coil support system for targeted back support and even pressure distribution;
  • Euro-top design with quilted gel memory foam for extra cushion and cooling.

The Winkbed has claimed its place in my review of the top 7 most comfortable mattresses for a few reasons. First and foremost, it offers a balanced feel and promotes even weight distribution. What’s more, it comes in four firmness options, with one of them being designed specifically for heavy users. This means the WinkBed can accommodate pretty much any sleeping position or body type, delivering both proper support and high comfort levels.

Depending on the model you choose, you can count on a zoned layer of springs or latex for more targeted support, or a sewn-in lumbar pad for better pressure relief in your lower back area. 

Along with that, each Winkbed mattress has a plush pillow-top padded with foam and infused with cooling gel, so you can expect both a reasonable amount of sinkage and cooler sleep.

Speaking of the basic features, the Winkbed has pretty sturdy edges, so you can be sure that the whole mattress area will be in use. However, models with a coil-on-coil design tend to be a bit too bouncy, which might be a turn-off for sensitive sleepers.

The Winkbed is very supportive and closely conforms to your spine. And the fact that the company caters to heavier users is just one of the many reasons why this mattress has made it onto this list.

Winkbed Mattress On a Bed Frame

Read our full Winkbed mattress review for more information.

Best for Side Sleepers — Zoma

Zoma Mattress

Click the button below to check current price 

Check Current Price


  • all-foam construction for superb pressure relief;
  • responsive transition layer to avert the quicksand feeling foam often causes;
  • zoned comfort layer to deliver pinpoint support.

The next model on our list of the most comfortable mattresses I would like to introduce is the Zoma mattress. This model can be a perfect solution for side sleepers. The Zoma is cradling and gentle on the protruding hip and shoulder, offering a deep hug that side sleepers require. Additionally, the mattress has a zoned layer that’s meant to provide optimal support for different parts of the body. As a result, the Zoma made me feel almost weightless, with zero tension in my back. This proves that the mattress can encourage a healthy alignment when lying on one side.

Now, this mattress also does a great job at absorbing shock from motion. I was testing it with my petite wife and she did not notice any motion transfer when I was tossing and turning. So, if you or your partner are a light sleeper, the Zoma mattress can help you enjoy undisturbed rest all through the night.

Zoma Mattress On a Bed Frame

Read our full Zoma mattress review for more information.

Best for People with Back Pain — Brooklyn Signature Hybrid

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid

Click the button below to check current price Check Current PriceGet 25% OFF


  • multiple size variations to fit any room and space (including RVs);
  • premium hybrid construction for a balanced combination of support and unparalleled tension alleviation;
  • three firmness options to satisfy more types of sleepers.

Looking for the most comfortable mattress that could help your back feel less tense and painful? Then you might want to consider the Signature Hybrid by Brooklyn Bedding. Combining resilient coils with conforming foam, this model has a balanced feel and can ensure proper spinal alignment during sleep. And healthy alignment means less pressure on the back, typically leading to pain relief. That’s what I experienced when testing the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid after straining my back at the gym.

The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid combines independent coils with three foam layers. The mattress doesn’t feel restricting but offers decent tension alleviation. As a combination sleeper (side and back), I appreciate that a lot. Most pressure-relieving mattresses make it hard for me to switch positions during sleep. However, I did not experience issues like that with the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid.

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid-P1066649
Brooklyn Bedding Construction

Read our full Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid review for more information.

Our Methodology - Why I Picked These Mattresses

These mattresses were chosen for their outstanding performance in comfort, balance, and temperature-neutral capabilities.

In my review methodology, I carefully compare mattresses, paying special attention to their feel and comfort. Comfort comes from a mattress’ ability to cushion, redistribute weight, and relieve pressure. When I test this, I take apart a mattress and examine each layer for its feel, and how bouncy or firm it is. Then, I lie on the mattress with all these layers in mind. If I notice my muscles releasing tension while my spine is supported, I consider the mattress as a potential candidate. I also consider how hot I feel on a mattress, as this can play a key role in a comfortable mattress. If I’m sleeping hot or feel suffocated in memory foam layers, I won’t feel comfortable. All the mattresses I’ve chosen are temperature neutral and are either breathable or have cool properties. My hands-on experience and hours of research all help me choose the most comfortable mattresses for your home.

What’s the Most Comfortable Mattress Type?

While scrolling through 7 most comfortable mattresses, you may start wondering: which mattress type is the best? After all, the market can boast of a wide variety of quality beds, each of which uses different materials. Here’s the deal: There’s no universally comfortable mattress type. They all have their peculiarities and special characteristics. While one mattress type appeals to certain users, it can also make others feel extremely uncomfortable. So, let’s look at the common bed types and see which one could work for you:

Memory foam

Created by NASA-funded researchers, memory foam was meant to provide enough cushioning for pilots during test flights. These days, the material has a simpler (but still important) role. Memory foam is used in quality mattresses to deliver a combination of superb support and pressure relief The visco-elastic chemicals in memory foam allow it to adapt to one’s body and its curves. This material offers close conforming and has a very slow response. It also absorbs motion quite well, which makes memory foam ideal for couples (especially sensitive sleepers). Due to its generous cushioning, memory foam is a popular option for arthritis and fibromyalgia patients.  However, some memory foam mattresses tend to sleep hot. If you are a heavier sleeper, you will sink in deeper, and that could make you overheat during the night. Some manufacturers use open-cell or gel-infused foam in their mattresses to make them more temperature-neutral.


Similar to memory foam, polyfoam is cushioning and supportive at the same time. It has a faster response and won’t make sleepers feel stuck in the bed. Manufacturers often combine different polyfoam densities to achieve a more balanced feel. The high-resiliency polyfoam tends to be of higher quality. It also has a longer lifespan, so you may want to check the foam type when shopping. Keep in mind that high-resiliency polyfoam is more expensive than regular grade material.


Innerspring mattresses use coils (mostly pocketed) for the support base. As for the comfort layer, it may be foam (usually thin) or micro-coils, depending on the model. Spring beds are favored for the stable, consistent support they provide. They usually have strong edges, which is a great option for couples who require more sleeping space. Innerspring mattresses are quite bouncy and allow for effortless moving and shifting. They are easy to get in and out of, which makes spring mattresses suitable for people with slight mobility issues. Additionally, coils are great for air circulation, which means spring beds most likely won’t sleep hot.


Natural latex is harvested from rubber trees. There’s also synthetic latex, which is usually made with a certain type of plastic. Both natural and synthetic latex conform closely to one’s body and offer superb pressure relief. However, latex is quite bouncy and doesn’t allow for too much sinkage. It might make you feel like you’re sleeping “on” your bed rather than “in” it. Another cool thing about latex mattresses is that they don’t trap heat, which makes them ideal for hot sleepers. Plus, latex mattresses are extremely durable. However, shoppers need to remember that this mattress type is among the most expensive ones.


Hybrid mattresses typically combine an innerspring support core and foam (sometimes latex) comfort layers. Such mattresses have a very balanced feel. They are supportive (even around the edges) and can effectively relieve pressure. Now, hybrid beds are quite expensive. They also tend to be thick and very heavy, which can become an issue if you plan to move. Nonetheless, this mattress type can be an ideal solution for sleepers who want something in the middle: not too hugging, not very bouncy. Hybrid mattresses also work great for hot sleepers, as this type has a breathable construction that aids thermoregulation.

Picking a Comfortable Mattress According to Your Sleeping Position

Even the comfiest bed in the world can make you feel terrible when it doesn’t suit your sleeping position.

So, to avoid that, let’s learn how to pick a suitable mattress according to how you typically sleep:

  • On your side. Side sleepers often develop sharp pressure points in their shoulders or hips. That’s why this sleeping style calls for softer mattresses that can provide enough cradling. Of course, the mattress shouldn’t be overly plush, as proper back support matters in this sleep position, too. It just has to offer a generous hug, while the base of the mattress has to keep the spine supported. If you are a side sleeper with shoulder pain, check out our 5 best mattresses for shoulder pain relief.
  • On your back. Back sleepers need proper support and spinal alignment. Additionally, they require a moderate amount of sinkage for the hips and buttocks. Medium firmness should be comfortable enough for this sleeping position. However, if you weigh more than 250 pounds, you should consider a medium-firm bed.
  • On your stomach. For this sleeping position, proper support is a must. Stomach sleepers are recommended to buy medium-firm (for lightweight individuals) or firm to extra-firm mattresses (for average and heavy people). This way, sleepers can avoid creating unhealthy curves in the spine and straining it during the night. Multiple factors may define whether the mattress would be comfortable enough for the sleeper.

    Here are a few examples of the key aspects:

As for combination sleepers, they tend to switch positions during the night. A suitable mattress should be responsive enough to allow for that. Medium firmness is recommended, but if you are heavier than average, you may want to try a medium-firm bed.

The Connection Between Body Weight and the Comfort Level of the Mattress

Some users overlook the fact that their weight can significantly affect their comfort. And if the mattress firmness does not suit the sleeper’s weight, even the best mattress can turn out to be extremely uncomfortable.

The thing is, this aspect is going to impact how the weight of the body affects the mattress materials. For example, heavier users tend to sink through the comfort layers, which means they need sturdier support. This is why larger folks are typically advised to pick slightly firmer mattresses for every sleeping style.

Lightweight individuals, on the other hand, often can’t compress the comfort layers. Their weight simply isn't enough for that. That’s why many comfortable mattresses can seem too stiff for them. Therefore, petite sleepers should stick to slightly softer models for each sleep position (especially side sleeping).

So, What Makes a Really Comfortable Mattress?

This question is probably the most important one when it comes to choosing a proper mattress. However, there’s no universal answer to it.

A few parameters that may define whether or not a bed will be comfortable enough for you do exist.

And I’ve listed them below to help you find the perfect mattress:

  • Edge support. A mattress with sturdy edges is less likely to start sagging within the first few years of use. It’s especially crucial if you spend a lot of time sitting on your mattress. Also, when the perimeter is strong, the whole mattress surface is available to you, which is important if you share a bed with someone. Typically, mattresses with coils have better edge support, but you can find a fairly sturdy perimeter in mattresses made of dense foam as well.
  • Motion response. This is a key component of uninterrupted sleep. Some mattresses, especially innerspring and hybrid ones, may be too bouncy and disrupt your shut-eye if your bedmate is an active sleeper (or if you allow your pet to sleep in your bed). Foam mattresses are best in this regard. They absorb the motion you or your partner might make during sleep, thus preventing you both from waking each other.
  • Thermoregulation. Sleeping on hot summer nights can be really uncomfortable. But for some people, any night can be that uncomfortable. If you’re prone to sleeping hot, choose natural and breathable materials such as latex, wool, or cotton. Also, mattresses with coils can promote better airflow. If you’re a fan of memory foam, which is known for trapping heat, look for beds made of foam with an open-cell structure. They will retain much less heat.


This is a subjective parameter tied to your body weight and preferred sleeping position. Consequently, the best mattresses are not always the firmest. 

First, you must consider your body size before choosing a champion.

  •  Heavy Sleeper. A firmer mattress is better since more weight implies more pressure on your mattress. Too much pressure on the bed might cause it to sink in, threatening spine alignment and resulting in back discomfort. 

A mattress with a firmness level of medium-firm or firm is normally recommended for people who weigh more than 230 pounds. This offers additional support for your weight, allowing you to sleep in optimal alignment.

  • Lightweight Sleepers. If you have a smaller frame, say 130 pounds or less, you'd want to go with a soft mattress. You won't be exerting much pressure on the mattress and, therefore, should be able to sink in properly. 

Once you've figured out your weight, your sleep posture comes next. For instance, side sleepers should go for anything in the 3-6/10 range, while back sleepers should look somewhere in the 5-7/10 range. 

The best way to find out what firmness level you need is to test a few mattresses at the store. Note that innerspring and hybrid mattresses typically feel a bit firmer than foam or latex mattresses of the same level of firmness. Check out our best extra-firm mattresses here.

  • Durability. You probably don’t want to replace your mattress every five years, so checking the durability is important. Read mattress user reviews to fully understand how well the bed performs. Remember that latex is believed to be the most long-lasting mattress material. Hybrid and innerspring models, which have coils inside, tend to be more resistant to sagging, and hence, may also serve you for quite a long time.
  • Compatibility with adjustable beds. Being able to use your mattress with an adjustable bed frame can take your comfort during sleep to a whole new level. Now, most modern mattresses work with adjustable beds, but it’s better to check the specifications when shopping for a new one (just in case). Foam and latex models usually work the best in this case, as they are very adaptive. Hybrid mattresses may also be suited for adjustable beds if they use independent pocketed (and not continuous) coils for the support core.
  • Thickness. The height of the mattress can also determine its comfort level. For instance, thinner mattresses are often firmer. They work well for back and stomach sleepers. Some thin mattresses may also suit heavier sleepers who require sturdier support, but only those models that use quality, reliable materials. Otherwise, a thin mattress might not be able to withstand more weight. As for taller models, they often have thicker comfort layers and can deliver more cradling. Thicker mattresses typically feel more luxurious. They can be an excellent solution for those users who need more cushioning and appreciate a deeper hug. Of course, there are also firm thick mattresses that feel more supportive. However, the number of options would be a bit more limited in this case.
  • Pressure relief. Getting pressure relief is vital for comfortable sleep. When the mattress conforms closely to the user’s body, it supports what needs to be supported (like the back curves, for example) and allows the heavier body parts to sink deeper. As a result, the weight is evenly distributed. This often causes tension levels to drop, helping sleepers relax. Additionally, pressure relief can be very effective when it comes to pain. Now, not all mattresses can offer the conforming needed for effective tension alleviation. Usually, memory foam models perform the best. Hybrid mattresses can also do the trick if they use thick-enough foam comfort layers. A good alternative would be latex. It’s not as hugging but can be adaptive and pressure-relieving nonetheless.


What mattress type is the most comfortable?

The most comfortable mattresses are typically memory foam ones (thanks to their pressure-alleviating properties). However, comfort is subjective. Some people prefer bouncier hybrids or latex mattresses. 

What mattress is the most comfortable for side sleepers?

The most comfortable mattress for side sleepers is a softer model. This sleeping style calls for a generous hug and lots of cushioning for the shoulder and hip. That’s why side sleepers usually feel the most comfortable when using soft mattresses.


Picking a comfortable mattress has never been easier.
After all, we have so many awesome models to choose from.

In my opinion, the most comfortable mattress would be the Puffy, as it has generous comfort layers, thick and deep cushioning that cradles the body, and a removable cover to help keep your bed clean.

Keep in mind that your new bed has to work for you. Pay attention to the firmness level in order to pick the one best suited for your specific sleeping position. Don’t forget about motion isolation if you share your bed with a significant other. And, of course, remember that all mattress materials have their unique feel: bouncy, responsive, cradling, resilient, and so on. Decide what will work for you and enjoy shopping!

Have you found a new favorite mattress in this selection? Tell me what factors are the most important to you when choosing a new bed? I’d love to know your opinion!



  1. William Bryan (Aug. 7, 2017). Memory foam from
  2. James Crown (2019, April 10). Is Latex Mattress Better Than Memory Foam? Retrieved from

Our research


Mattresses Considered


Hours of Research


Sleep Experts Consulted

Subscribe to get updates and new deals!

Zero spam. Unsubscribe at any time

Leave a comment