Clicky

5 Best Casper Mattress Alternatives

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission with no extra cost to you. Learn More

Written by: Alex Savy
Read 20 minLast updated on November 17, 2022

If you like the feel of Casper mattresses but you’ve had an unpleasant experience with the company, or if you need just a tiny adjustment to that Casper feel, there are many mattresses that are equally good or better, and even at a lower price. In this article, I will help you to find a Casper mattress alternative that is great. 

Quick Review of Best Casper Mattress Alternatives

Casper Mattress

Best Alternative Option

Casper Original Mattress Tempur Cloud Mattress
Casper Original Hybrid Mattress Chill Hybrid Mattress
Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress Saatva Classic Mattress
Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress WinkBeds Luxury Hybrid Mattress
Casper Element Mattress Amerisleep AS3 12" Memory Foam Mattress

Our Reviews of the Best Casper Mattress Alternatives  

Tempur Cloud Mattress - For Better Support Than the Casper Original

TEMPUR-Cloud

A rigid and dense mattress core which provides support for the Tempur cloud balances out the plushier top, as a result of this providing the better support between the two. 

  • Construction

Although the two mattresses are made up of strictly foam parts and similar setups, the Casper original is one inch thicker than the Tempur cloud.

  • Firmness

Both mattresses have a medium-firm feel suitable for combination, back, and side sleepers. While this is great for motion isolation, the Tempur Cloud is comfier because it has a thicker top foam layer than the Casper Original.  

  • Support and Pressure Relief

The Casper Original mattress uses a zoned transition layer (three sections with a firmer midsection) to relieve body tension differently for various pressure points. However, the Tempur Cloud uses a malleable transition layer that responds to the body’s needs for pressure relief. This means that sleepers can feel evenly cradled across all pressure points and get more pressure relief than Casper offers. 

  • Coolness

Casper Original uses a perforated top foam to maximize breathability and soak away heat. At the same time, the Tempur Cloud depends on a wick-like cover in combination with the soft top layer for cooling. Overall, sleepers won’t sleep hot on either mattress, so it's a stalemate here. 

  • Environmental Concerns

CertPUR-US certified that both mattresses use negligible VOCs. In addition, Casper uses recycled plastic bottles, while Tempur cloud has shifted its production operations to strictly renewable energy. Sensitive and environmentally-conscious sleepers get an edge with the Tempur Cloud. 

  • Price and Perks

The Casper is about $300 cheaper than the Tempur cloud. Both mattresses have a 10-year limited warranty, with the Casper having a 100-day sleep trial while the Tempur cloud has a 90-day sleep trial. 

While these two hybrid mattresses took similar approaches toward maximizing comfort for the user, the Chill mattress comes as a cooler and better budget option. 

  • Construction

Casper mattress uses a plush top, a transition layer, and a spring base bounded at the edges by a dense foam. Similarly, the Chill Hybrid mattress uses two layers of foam at the top with pocketed springs at the core, albeit bounded at the sides by reinforced pocketed coils, and at the bottom with a dense foam layer. In essence, the Chill Hybrid mattress has better edge support and would offer more body support for heavy sleepers because its core and coils are thicker than those of the Casper Original Hybrid.

  • Firmness

The plush top of both mattresses puts their firmness at medium-firm. Just the right amount for optimal motion isolation, suitable for partnered sleepers who have different sleep preferences. A medium-firm mattress like the Chill Hybrid would both serve sleepers that want plush comfort and those that need weight support. 

  • Support and Pressure Relief

The Chill Hybrid mattress uses a plushier top layer and a thicker transition layer for pressure relief. Its pocketed coils provide consistent support throughout the foam base for proper spinal alignment. Meanwhile, the Casper Original hybrid mattress also features a plush top with a less thick zone transition layer and inner coils for support. So, in comparison, the Chill Hybrid adapts better to the sleeper’s body shape to offer slightly more effective pressure relief. 

  • Coolness

Casper Hybrid uses a perforated top layer and well-aerated pocketed coils for improved breathability and easy body heat dissipation. So, the Casper Hybrid bed allows for more airflow than the Chill Hybrid. But the Chill Hybrid bed isn’t a no-no for hot sleepers as it features a phase change cover that reacts to body heat and can have a cooling effect on hot nights. 

  • Environmental Concerns

Both mattresses are CertiPUR-US certified for low counts of harmful chemicals to the body and the environment. So, both the Chill Hybrid mattress works for sensitive sleepers who want an alternative to the Casper Hybrid  

  • Price and Perks

The Chill mattress is about $500 cheaper than the Casper mattress. Both mattresses come with a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty. However, the Chill mattress has two free pillows and a bed sheet bundle. 

Saatva Classic Mattress – For More Firmness Options Than the Casper Wave Hybrid

Saatva Classic Mattress

With a much lower price point and far more firmness selections, the Saatva Classic provides a great alternative to the Casper Wave with its high price and lack of firmness options.

Construction

The Casper Wave has six inches of coils for support, a layer of polyfoam with gel pods in the middle, and several layers of zoned memory foam, open-cell latex, and open-cell polyfoam for comfort. The Saatva Classic has two layers of coils, two layers of polyfoam, and a top comfort layer of memory foam. Thus, both are solidly constructed with great materials and are two of the best hybrid mattresses around. 

The Casper is 13 inches and the Saatva either 11.5 or 14.5 inches in height, and the Saatva is also a great mattress for platform beds. 

Firmness

The Casper is medium on the firmness scale, which is perfect for side sleepers, appropriate for back sleepers, and too soft for stomach sleepers.

The Saatva comes in options of soft, medium-firm, and firm, so you can choose according to your preferences.

Support and Pressure Relief

Both mattresses use plenty of thick coils for bouncy support, but the Casper excels with extra support. It also uses two zones in the comfort layer and gel pods below your lower back in the mid-layer to support your spine, while the Saatva has a memory foam lumbar pad for the same purpose.

For pressure relief, both mattresses have thick polyfoam and memory foam comfort layers.

Coolness

The Casper has a slight upper hand here with its open-cell perforated materials and cooling gel in the top two layers, while the polyfoam and fiber in the Saatva are also cooler than memory foam. The Saatva's cotton cover draws more heat away from your body than the Casper's mixture of polyester, cotton, and rayon does.

Since both use coils for support, both sleep cooler than pure memory foam mattresses do.

Environmental Concerns

Both mattresses use CertiPUR-US® certified memory foam to confirm that they're free from ozone-depleting chemicals and low in volatile organic compound emissions.

Price and Perks

The Saatva's $1,400 is far preferable to the Casper's $3,200, and it also comes with a 15-year warranty and 180-night sleep trial, versus the Casper's 10-year warranty and 100-night sleep trial.

Both offer free in-home setup and removal of your old mattress.

Read our full Saatva mattress review for more information.

With a lower price and four firmness options, the WinkBeds Luxury is suitable for far more sleepers than the Casper Nova with its high price and lack of firmness selections.

Construction

Both of these are hybrid mattresses with coils in the support layer and combinations of polyfoam and memory foam in the middle and on top. 

Firmness

The Casper is medium on the firmness scale, while the WinkBed hybrid comes in four firmness options, from medium-soft, to medium, to medium-firm, to firm. As such, the WinkBed is appropriate for anyone, while the Casper is best for side sleepers, and possibly back light-weight sleepers. The WinkBeds is also a great mattress for Adjustable Beds. 

Read our full Winkbed mattress review for more information.

WinkBeds Mattress Side Sleeping
Winkbed Mattress On a Bed Frame

Support and Pressure Relief

Both mattresses use a combination of polyfoam and memory foam to provide pressure relief, but the rest of their support and pressure relief systems differ.

The Casper's top polyfoam layer has three support zones, and its transitional memory foam layer below that is divided into seven zones. As such, it provides firm support below your lower back and sinkage below your hips and shoulders.

The WinkBed uses zones in its coiled system to provide extra support below your lower back.

Coolness

Both mattresses use gel infused foam that is simultaneously open cell to improve airflow through the mattresses in order to lead your body heat away. Casper uses its own patented foam called AirScape, but whether it is better at cooling than normal open-cell foam is not entirely clear.

Environmental Concerns

Coils and foam aren't particularly environmentally friendly, except for the fact that both manufacturers use CertiPUR-US® certified memory foam.

Price and Perks

At $2,300, Casper is again more expensive than WinkBed's $1,600. Both ship for free and you are responsible for the setup process. Casper and WinkBeds give a 100 and 120-night sleep trial respectively.

With a thicker core and more support zones, the Amerisleep AS3 is a better option than the Casper Original in the all-foam class.

Construction

Both mattresses are made of all-memory foam. The Amerisleep mattress is 1 inch thicker than the Casper. These are great motion isolation mattresses for couples in which one person is a restless sleeper.

Firmness

Both these mattresses are around medium on the firmness scale, ideal for back and side sleepers. 

Support and Pressure Relief

The Casper Original Mattress has three support zones, while the Amerisleep AS3 12" Memory Foam Mattress has five. This means that the Casper has only the most necessary soft section below your shoulders and firmer section below your lower back, while the Amerisleep tries to go further by also supporting your head, by lifting your legs, and by protecting your hips and ribs from contact pressure with the mattress. As such, they are equally good at back support, but the Amerisleep mattress is probably better at reducing contact pressure.

Coolness

Since they are both foam mattresses, neither sleeps particularly cool. The Casper uses perforated foam to stay cool while the Amerisleep uses its own open-cell Bio-Pur memory foam that is breathable, removing the heat from below your body and allowing air to flow. Both use polyester and cotton covers to reduce the temperature between your body and the mattress.

Environmental Concerns

The Casper uses recycled plastic bottles and its cover, while the Amerisleep's Bio-Pur memory foam has a lot of its petrochemicals replaced with plant oils. 

Price and Perks

At approximately $1,400, they cost the same, and both also come with a 100-night sleep trial. But while the Casper mattress comes with a 10-year warranty, the Amerisleep is guaranteed for 20 years. Both are delivered in boxes for you to move to the room of your choice.

Read our full Amerisleep AS3 mattress review for more information.
Side Sleeping on Amerisleep Mattress
Amerisleep AS5 On a Bed Frame

Why Choose Mattresses Similar to Casper?

Casper is a good manufacturer with solid offerings and a good reputation. So why might one look for mattresses similar to Casper?

  • Casper mattresses are almost all in the medium category on the firmness scale. On a scale of 10, they all rank at five or six, which is perfect for side sleepers. Back sleepers, stomach sleepers, and sleepers that weigh above 230 pounds may need a bed that is a bit firmer, though, like these best mattresses for heavy people. Similarly, light-weight sleepers may enjoy beds that are softer.
  • Casper mattresses are relatively expensive. If you look at the prices of the Casper Original and Casper Original Hybrid, the only technology they incorporate is perforated foam and three support zones, but they still cost approximately $1,400. As you can see from our preferred beds like Casper, you can have more advanced technology for that price, such as better pressure relief, more support zones, and a thicker mattress for longevity. The same is true if you move up the price scale to Casper's more expensive offerings. This price difference is probably due to the fact that Casper mattresses are also available in brick-and-mortar stores instead of simply online, which increases the price.
  • Casper mattresses come with only 10 years of limited warranty, after which you have to pay the full cost of a new mattress. Most of the other mattresses give you the same warranty for the first 10 years, but then give you an extra 10 or 15 years during which you can replace your mattress and only half the cost of the new one. GhostBed, for example, guarantees its mattress against one-inch sag below heavy body parts and other manufacturing defects for 10 years, after which you can buy a new GhostBed for only 50 or 40 percent of the price for the next 15 years. This kind of deal guarantees that you can get cheap mattresses for the rest of your life if you find a brand that you like.
  • If you cannot handle the setup process on your own, Casper's additional in-room setup costs a full $149 compared with the free service from Saatva and the cheaper service from WinkBeds. GhostBed is more expensive, however.

Also Read: Tempurpedic Alternatives

Important Considerations When Buying a Mattress Online

Online shopping for mattresses is incredibly convenient. You visit a website, click on a purchase link, provide your credit card details, wait for the box to arrive, and move it into the bedroom where you want it to expand until you can use it. Best of all, brands that sell online are cheaper because they don't have to pay for retail space.

Casper, Amerisleep, Natural Form, Saatva, WinkBeds, and GhostBed all utilize this easy system. 

But there are some important things to keep in mind when you buy mattresses online.

  • Perks tend to be guaranteed only if you buy the mattresses on the manufacturers' websites. Claiming the benefits after ordering from Amazon is a hit-and-miss experience with many disappointed customers finding out only later that they missed out. For what it's worth, Casper claims that it fulfils the perks when you buy on Amazon, but the customer reviews suggest that it is not so easy.
  • Manufacturers often offer discounts on their own websites, so if there is a specific mattress you want, check its website every week in case there is a special. As mentioned above, Casper's mattresses are relatively expensive, you can sometimes get away with paying less. The same is true for its competitors like Amerisleep, Natural Form, Saatva, WinkBeds, and GhostBed who make beds like Casper.

F.A.Q.

How Do I Pick a Casper Mattress Alternative?

Find another mattress with the same or very similar construction, firmness, support, and pressure relief properties. For example:

  • For the Casper Original, pick an all-foam mattress with memory and polyfoam with at least three support zones. 
  • For the Casper Original Hybrid, pick a mattress with a foam comfort layer on top of a coil support layer with at least three support zones.

Is it Possible to Find a Mattress Identical to Casper?

Probably not. All manufacturers use their own proprietary technology and materials, the details of which they do not release for other manufacturers to copy. For example, Casper uses Zoned Support™ Pro for support zones and AirScape™ for cooling. The best you can do is to buy another mattress with support zones and perforated or open-cell foam to try to replicate the features of the Casper.

What is the Best Casper Alternative for Non-Side Sleepers?

Good question. Since the medium firmness of the Casper mattresses make them inappropriate for heavy sleepers, stomach sleepers, and some back sleepers, you need a mattress that is medium-firm or firm; in this case, Saatva or WinkBeds.

Conclusion

If you've had an issue with Casper or with a Casper mattress, you now know how to choose Casper mattress alternatives. Find another mattress with approximately the same construction materials, firmness, support, and pressure relief features, and then adjust it as needed, such as choosing a firmer option for a heavier sleeper or opting for a cheaper mattress with the same features.

If you have come across a good Casper stand-in mattress, let us know what we've missed in the comments below.

 

Our research

27

Mattresses Considered

112

Hours of Research

2

Sleep Experts Consulted

Subscribe to get updates and new deals!

Zero spam. Unsubscribe at any time

Leave a comment