This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission with no extra cost to you. Learn More
So you’ve just purchased a brand new mattress, and you’re so excited to use it for years to come. Mattresses are a crowning achievement for the bedroom, especially if they’re on the luxury end like memory foam, and you want to make sure your investment lasts as long as possible.
A quick way to ruin that investment is by making a stain on the mattress, unfortunately. With only spot-cleaning options available, you either have to deal with a messy spot for the rest of the years you’re using the mattress or buy a new one.
That can easily be avoided by buying a mattress protector. Mattress protectors are designed to be pleasant to sleep on while protecting your mattress from spills and stains. This allows you to have breakfast in bed every day of the week without worrying about the orange juice making a mess on your comfortable sleeping area.
I’ve put together a list of my best waterproof mattress protectors that I think are the best at protecting your mattress from spills, and ensuring that it lasts you and your household for a long time.
Let’s get into it.
A Quick Preview
 | Best Overall - Editor’s Choice Puffy Mattress Protector | Check Current Price Read more about this mattress protector |
 | Runner Up Organic Cotton Mattress Protector by Nolah | Check Current Price Read more about this mattress protector |
 | Best for All Mattress Types Classic Mattress Protector by Plushbeds | Check Current Price Read more about this mattress protector |
 | Best for Partnered Sleepers GhostProtector | Check Current Price Read more about this mattress protector |
 | Best for High-Profile Mattresses BreatheCool Mattress Protector by WinkBeds | Check Current Price Read more about this mattress protector |
 | Best for Hot Sleepers Mattress Protector by Amerisleep | Check Current Price Read more about this mattress protector |
Our Reviews of the Best Waterproof Mattress Protectors
Best Overall - Editor’s Choice — Puffy Mattress Protector
Click the button below to check current price
Check Current Price Read our detailed reviewHighlights
- Constructed from an incredible bamboo rayon fabric, the mattress protector is great at heat dispersal.
- It is quiet to the touch, offering little to no noise while in use.
- The mattress protector comes equipped with durable elastic pockets that can stretch to accommodate different types of mattresses.
A waterproof mattress protector is counted as part of the best only when it meets some certain standards, all of which the Puffy Mattress Protector has met. Made from natural forest materials, it's a remarkable product that protects the mattress against all forms of liquid dirt.
By being washable and hypoallergenic, it eases the cleaning process and ensures that a user's mattress is free from bacteria, dirt, mold, mites, and other allergy causing irritants. The Puffy mattress protector is a product made to last, and the company proves this claim by adding a lifetime warranty clause to the product.
In addition, the fabric is excellent for temperature regulation as it allows breathability and optimal airflow. Coupling this with its noiseless feature, it is a product that deserves to be ranked among the best waterproof mattress protectors available on the market.
Recommended for:
- Those who suffer from allergies. Despite being already hypoallergenic, the mattress protector is still machine washable. Effectively ensuring that the mattress is free of all forms of allergens.
- Users who want a snug fit. With the deep pockets of this mattress protector, it is able to comfortably cover various mattress sizes.
- Shoppers looking for a long lasting investment. Equipped with a lifetime warranty feature, it'll be excellent for individuals in search of a durable product.
Cons:
- It cannot cover mattresses denser than 15 inches.
- Despite being breathable, it can make a person sleep warmer than usual.
Runner Up — Organic Cotton Mattress Protector by Nolah
Click the button below to check current price
Check Current Price Read our detailed reviewHighlights
- stretchy fabric to prevent body imprints;
- deep pockets to accommodate even taller mattresses;
- natural fabric for enhanced breathability and cooler sleep.
The next item on our list of the best waterproof mattress protectors is the Nolah. And the first thing I’ve noticed about this model was its quiet yet effective performance. The Nolah mattress protector doesn’t make crinkly noises when there’s movement on top, probably because the waterproof lining is extra thin. This means the Nolah can be used even by light sleepers who are easily awakened during the night. At the same time, this mattress protector doesn’t let the moisture through. I’ve tested it with my morning coffee (risky, I know). The mattress remained dry and stain-free, even after I’ve left the coffee sit for a bit.
I also like how stretchy yet sturdy the Nolah’s fabric is. It slips onto the mattress like a second skin and adapts to the sleeper’s body. However, the fabric quickly returns to its shape when there’s no one in bed, preventing body imprints. Therefore, the Nolah is likely to deliver long-lasting performance and will look like new for a long time.
Recommended for:
- Owners of high-profile mattresses. The Nolah mattress protector has deep elastic pockets and can work with mattresses up to 16 inches high. It’s an excellent option for taller hybrid or pillow-top models.
- Light sleepers. This mattress protector isn’t noisy (unlike many waterproof competitors). That’s why the Nolah won’t be likely to disturb light sleepers who need a quiet environment to enjoy their restful slumber.
- Those who tend to run hot during sleep. The cotton mattress protector by Nolah allows for unobstructed air circulation, which can help sleepers maintain a neutral temperature. Cotton also wicks the excess moisture away fast, contributing to thermoregulation.
Cons:
- does not protect the mattress from dust mites and bed bugs, as this model does not work like a full encasement;
- might fit low-profile mattresses somewhat too loosely (resulting in folds and wrinkles).
Best for All Mattress Types — Classic Mattress Protector by Plushbeds
Click the button below to check current price Check Current Price Read our detailed review
Highlights
- suited for mattresses that are 6 to 22 inches thick;
- certified liquid-proof lining;
- hypoallergenic.
Looking for the best waterproof mattress protector that will be sure to work with your mattress height? Then you might want to consider the Classic Mattress Protector by Plushbeds. This model was designed to accommodate any mattress from 6 to 22 inches tall (thanks to its elastic pockets). Therefore, you don’t have to worry about the depth of the pockets and the height of your mattress. Order, unpack, and put it on - and your mattress is safe with no effort.
Now, I also appreciate that this mattress protector is very pleasant to the touch. It uses weaved polyester for the top layer and has a good level of elasticity. As a result, the fabric adjusts to the mattress and the body’s shape. This allows the mattress protector by Plushbeds to retain its shape instead of stretching out and thinning.
Overall, this model is a good option for those who want great value for money and effective protection for their mattress.
Recommended for:
- Sleepers who are prone to allergies. The lining of this mattress protector is hypoallergenic, so you are safe even if you’re a bit more sensitive.
- Someone who wants a snug fit. Thanks to the convenient elastic, the Plushbeds mattress protector is easy to put on a mattress. Plus, it fits nicely and cannot be felt through the sheets.
- Families with kids. This mattress protector can deal with different amounts of liquid, which will protect your baby’s mattress while you are still potty training.
Cons:
- not effective against bed bugs;
- can make you sleep warmer than usual.
Best for Partnered Sleepers — GhostProtector
Click the button below to check current price
Check Current Price Read our detailed review
Highlights
- fully waterproof without any plastic components;
- extra-thick elastic band for proper encasement and to guarantee a secure fit;
- cotton-blend fabric for increased breathability.
For active sleepers/sensitive sleepers who tend to toss and turn during the night, this waterproof mattress protector solves two huge problems. The product uses extra-thick elastic bands to help keep the protector snug and in place on the mattress, while also ensuring a crinkle-free usage. It is a feature particularly beneficial for partnered sleepers.
The best waterproof mattress protector has to be durable and reliable. And that’s exactly what the GhostProtector can offer. It is well-made, which means it can protect your mattress for years to come. Everything, from fabric to the seams feels sturdy. Additionally, the GhostProtector has a quality elastic band that guarantees a secure fit. I mean, it managed to deliver reliable performance even when I was tossing and turning in bed constantly.
Another aspect you might appreciate is that the GhostProtector does not make any noise. This mattress protector doesn’t use plastic as its waterproof component, which means you will hear no crinkly sounds when moving on top of it. Additionally, it’s super soft and pleasant to the touch. The GhostProtector combines a cotton blend with a soft knit to achieve improved breathability and comfort.
All things considered, this model is a real gem. It would come in especially handy for active couples and restless sleepers who want their mattress to remain secure all through the night.
Recommended for:
- Light sleepers. If you can be easily woken up by even light sounds, the GhostProtector could be a perfect solution as this model doesn’t make any noise when there’s movement on top of it.
- Allergy-prone users. The GhostProtector uses a special antimicrobial technology that helps minimize the number of potential allergens, keeping the sleeping environment fresh and safe.
- Active or restless sleepers. This model has an extra-thick elastic band that can easily keep the mattress protector in place during the night.
Cons:
- will not protect the mattress against bed bugs (as it is styled as a fitted sheet, not a full encasement);
- not very cheap, which may not work for shoppers on a budget.
Best for High-Profile Mattresses – BreatheCool Mattress Protector by WinkBeds
Click the button below to check current price Check Current Price Read our detailed review
Highlights
- hypoallergenic and safe for sensitive users;
- special FitSkirt design to work with mattresses up to 18 inches thick;
- natural cotton cover for more breathability.
Being among the best waterproof mattress protectors, the BreatheCool has a lot to boast of. Many users appreciate its versatility, as this mattress protector can work with any mattress thanks to its fitted design and deep pockets.
The BreatheCool is suited for mattresses up to 18 inches tall. It comes in 6 sizes at a very reasonable price. And since this mattress protector is 100% waterproof, it can prolong the lifespan of your bed.
Another great thing about this item is the fact that it’s safe even for allergy-prone sleepers or someone who has sensitive skin. The BreatheCool uses natural cotton for the top layer, which is breathable, safe, and soft to the touch.
All in all, this mattress protector is definitely worth your attention. It is reliable and versatile in use, as it can work with almost any mattress.
Recommended for:
- Allergy-prone sleepers. Thanks to the natural top layer, this mattress protector is safe even for sensitive users.
- Owners of high-profile mattresses. The BreatheCool is suitable for tall mattresses thanks to its special design.
- Someone who wants a secure fit. This mattress protector has a non-slip construction and would work for restless sleepers or someone who wants the protector to sit on their mattress as tightly as possible.
Cons:
- not an encasement, so it doesn’t guarantee protection against dust mites;
- might make you sleep warmer than usual because of the waterproof lining.
Best for Hot Sleepers — Mattress Protector by Amerisleep
Click the button below to check current price
Check Current Price Read our detailed reviewHighlights
- breathable construction to promote air circulation and aid temperature regulation;
- 100% waterproof and can easily withstand regular spills (great for those who love breakfasts in bed);
- fitted-sheet design for a secure fit.
Many waterproof mattress protectors sleep hot because of that water-repellent lining. However, that’s not the case with the Amerisleep, making it one of the best waterproof mattress protectors for hot sleepers. This model has a cotton-blend jersey top that allows for unobstructed air circulation. And when there’s breathability, there are more chances to sleep cooler. I, for one, did not experience any heat retention, even when sleeping on one side and being hugged by the mattress (and the protector material).
The warranty coverage by Amerisleep was another happy discovery. This mattress protector comes with a 5-year warranty, which can be a good indication of its quality. Another proof lies in the sturdy feel of this mattress protector. It managed to withstand all of my tests, which included constant spills, frequent washing, tossing and rolling around, and even pets jumping on the bed.
Recommended for:
- Those who hate sleeping hot. The Amerisleep mattress protector is more breathable than many competitors, allowing it to create a temperature-neutral sleep environment.
- Shoppers looking for a long-lasting investment. This model is very well-made, with neat seams and secure pockets. Plus, it comes with 5-year warranty coverage, which means the manufacturer is sure of this mattress protector’s durability.
- Allergy-prone sleepers. The Amerisleep mattress protector is hypoallergenic and OEKO-TEX certified. Needless to say, it’s safe even for sensitive users. Plus, this model by Amerisleep can withstand frequent washes, which means sleepers can regularly get rid of the allergens in their bed.
Cons:
- not the most budget-friendly option;
- can make crinkly sounds, which isn’t ideal for extremely light sleepers.
Do You Really Need a Waterproof Mattress Protector?
Yes, you do.
Let me explain why
The first and perhaps the most important is the issues with the warranty. Many manufacturers provide an opportunity to replace or repair their mattress for free if your complaint falls under warranty conditions. But the warranty will be voided if the mattress has spills or stains on its surface.
In this case, the repair might cost you a pretty penny.
Mattress factories have high sanitary standards for their employees. Since many different diseases can be transmitted through bodily fluids, any traces and stains on the mattress make the replacement or repair impossible.
The second thing is that even materials of the highest quality under the influence of external factors eventually become unable to perform their functions perfectly. With mattresses, those external factors accelerating wear and tear are the following:
- direct sunlight;
- friction with your body;
- dead skin cells and other organic material;
- debris and dust particles.
A mattress protector is an excellent way to minimize the influence of these factors. Many models allow you to keep the proper air circulation inside the mattress, thus reducing the risk of such issues as mildew and mold, as well as the unpleasant smells following them.
And the best part is:
Most toppers can be removed and washed.
It’s much easier and cheaper than calling a specialist who would carry out a deep cleaning of the mattress itself.
Now, a mattress protector can be a worthy purchase if you or your partner have sensitive skin or are prone to allergies.
Alas, allergens surround us constantly: dust mites, pet dander, our own sweat and other organic particles that promote the growth of different microorganisms inside the mattress can cause asthma-like symptoms, stuffy nose, rashes on the body, or itching (1).
Therefore, to improve the quality of life — and not to wake up with watery eyes and a stuffy nose every morning — a good waterproof mattress protector is a reasonable investment.
Don’t forget to regularly clean it, though.
What Types of Waterproof Mattress Protectors Are There?
In order to choose the best waterproof mattress protector for your bed, you should understand what types there actually are and what advantages each type comes with.
Let’s start.
Style Types
All mattress protectors on the market today can be divided into three general categories:
- encasements (or zippered) — these protect your mattress entirely (including the top, bottom, and sides) and, as the name implies, they are fastened with a zipper;
- fitted covers — being the most common option on the market, these look like a sheet with pocketed corners, so you can stretch them over mattresses of various thickness;
- pads with elastic straps — these usually cover only the top of the mattress, being attached to it with the help of elastic straps at the corners.
The type of mattress protector directly dictates the features of its use.
Thus, protecting encasements are the most versatile. They serve as a shield from allergens and dust, maintain airflow inside the mattress, protect against bed bugs and accidental spills of liquid, and are useful for those who have pets at home.
Fitted protectors are an option if you only need protection against spills and stains and the ability to make your sleep more comfortable, as some models can provide more cushioning or a cooling effect.
Quick note: A fitted design doesn’t cover the bottom part of a mattress, which can promote better air circulation if your bed frame consists of wooden slats.
Strapped protectors are somewhat similar to fitted ones but are a more basic option. Most models of this design are not waterproof and serve only as a shield from debris accumulation and normal wear and tear.
Fabric Types
Let’s talk fabric.
It’s the first thing that affects our visual and kinesthetic impressions from a waterproof mattress protector.
Cotton, linen, and other natural fabrics are an excellent choice for those who need a durable cover for everyday use. They are breathable, very soft to the touch, but hygroscopic, so a stronger waterproof layering is needed for it to effectively save your mattress from spillages.
Polyester is the best option if you are looking for protection from leakage and accidental stains, as it’s less absorbent. Since it is a synthetic fiber, it is very resilient and can effectively protect your mattress from both leaks and the formation of unwanted moisture inside it. But in terms of the feel, it might be as soft as natural fabrics.
Rayon & lyocell fabrics are chemically obtained by treating cellulose made from wood. They are environmentally safe, resistant to active use, and are great for those who are suffering from allergies.
Vinyl Vs Polyurethane Waterproof Protection
According to reviews of waterproof mattress protectors, the most commonly chosen waterproof materials in recent years are polyurethane and vinyl (PVC). Today, though, more and more manufacturers are refusing the latter in favor of the former and other alternatives.
Why?
The fact is that polyvinyl chloride can release toxic chemicals into the air (2), including chlorine, phthalates, and bisphenol A. Being exposed to these substances can lead to disorders of the endocrine and reproductive systems, as well as to some oncological diseases.
Therefore, it’s highly recommended that you choose vinyl-free products.
What to Consider When Shopping for a Waterproof Mattress Topper
Now, before we proceed to waterproof mattress protector reviews, here are a few more things you need to keep in mind.
Temperature control
If you live in a hot or cold climate, you need to pay attention to protectors that have good thermoregulatory properties. These are the ones that keep you from sweating on hot nights and keep you warm on cold nights. Cotton, wool, and other natural materials are a great option for that.
Allergies
If you suffer from allergies, asthma, and other respiratory, the most suitable choice for you would be a zippered encasement. It completely covers the mattress and, therefore, is the most effective at preventing dust and allergens from accumulating inside the mattress.
Bed bugs
No one likes talking about them.
And, of course, no one wants to find them in their bed.
Usually, bed bugs don’t come from nowhere. They can travel between units in apartment buildings or can be accidentally brought by you from other places (via luggage or used items you purchase) (3). But they won’t linger in your home if there’s no favorable environment for them. And a full encasement is exactly what will help you here, as they create a shield for all 6 sides of your bed.
If you are worried that your mattress topper will alter the feel of your mattress, go for the one made of materials similar to the materials used in a cover of your mattress.
Noise levels
Waterproof lining in mattress protectors often comes with the price: crinkly noises. For some users, they may seem too irritating. To avoid that, shoppers might want to read customer reviews attentively. In many cases, users mention if their waterproof mattress protectors turned out to be too noisy, which can help other shoppers avoid products like that.
Durability
This is another aspect shoppers can check by reading other users’ reports. Durability is crucial, especially for those sleepers who plan to wash their mattress protector frequently due to bedwetting or other circumstances. So, by checking the reviews, shoppers can get a general idea of how the mattress protector they are considering would hold up with regular use.
Warranty
Some mattress protectors come with warranties against defects, which can be a good indication of their quality. However, most warranties do not cover normal wear and tear, so shoppers need to inquire about that aspect to prevent any misunderstanding or disappointment in the future.
Mattress thickness
Regardless of the protector type, it has to work for the height of the mattress. This is especially important for shoppers who are considering a full encasement or a fitted protector. As for pads that use elastic straps, they are often adjustable or stretchy, so the straps typically work for different mattress types.
How to Care for Your Mattress Protector?
A good waterproof mattress pad perfectly protects the mattress from most accidents, but it also requires a thorough and regular cleaning. If you follow these tips, the cleaning process will always be fuss-free for you:
- Refer to the manufacturer’s care guidelines. Normally, there’s a label on a product, indicating the acceptable temperature regimes for washing and drying and the recommended frequency of these procedures. If you do not have access to the manual, a good rule of thumb is to wash your topper every 1.5-2 months regardless of whether you’ve had any spills or not.
- Use bleach-free laundry detergents. Bleaching agents can damage plastic fibers, which are usually used as a waterproof backing, or ruin the material binding the waterproof and the surface layer.
- Choose laundry settings wisely. For materials such as cotton or wool, you can use the normal washing cycle, and for polyester or viscose, the delicate washing cycle is required.
- Don’t tumble dry using high temperatures. That’s because the hot air can damage the fibers, and they will shrink. Also, high temperatures may ruin the waterproof membrane. If you are unable to air dry your topper, you can tumble dry it on low settings along with towels and bedsheets. But ironing is still not recommended.
Some manufacturers recommend that you wash the topper as soon as you get it out of the package. This is said to help you get rid of the factory odor and, in some cases, make the fabric softer. But it’s just a recommendation, so it’s always better to address the customer service and ask them if that’s a good thing to do with their particular product.
F.A.Q.
Where can I buy a waterproof mattress protector?
Amazon has an impressively wide selection of waterproof mattress protectors. Additionally, you can check manufacturers’ websites directly, especially if you are interested in a specific brand.
Do mattress protectors actually work?
Yes. Waterproof mattress protectors prevent moisture, dust, dead skin cells, body oils, and other stuff from accumulating inside the mattress. As a result, they can also prevent dust mites, bed bugs, and mold growth. This means the mattress’s lifespan can increase significantly with the help of this simple accessory.
Can a mattress protector make a bed more comfortable?
Yes, but only to a certain extent. It is possible when the mattress protector comes with additional padding. However, such models aren’t very common among waterproof mattress protectors. Additionally, the padding is typically quite thin and, thus, won’t be likely to affect one’s comfort that much.
Conclusion
Choosing a mattress protector can be a daunting task. But if done right, it can significantly expand the lifespan of your mattress and your overall comfort. I hope that this buyer’s guide will be a good start for you when it comes to choosing your ideal model. And to find the best option, don’t forget to pay attention to the following aspects:
- Type. Whether it works like a fitted sheet or a full mattress encasement, you need to figure out the ideal solution for your particular needs. Remember that a fitted sheet protector will not be able to keep the bed bugs and dust mites away from your mattress. At the same time, fitted protectors allow for better breathability and can help keep your mattress fresh.
- Fabric. The abundance of options makes it hard to choose the best type, but I always recommend picking natural fabrics over synthetic ones due to their breathability.
- Waterproof lining. Polyurethane and vinyl are the two most common options, but the former turns out to be the winner in most cases.
Taking a look at the Puffy mattress protector, it is an incredible product that ticks all the boxes and more of what's required in a waterproof mattress protector. Noiseless, machine washable,and breathable; the Puffy mattress protector keeps your bed free from spills,stains, and all other types of liquid damage.
Have you used a waterproof mattress protector before? Did it provide the expected level of protection? You’re welcome to share your experience in the comments!
References
- Julia Calderone (2015, October 29). A simple adjustment to your bed could dramatically reduce your allergies. Retrieved from https://www.businessinsider.com/allergies-mattress-pillow-cover-bed-fungus-dust-2015-10
- U.S. National Library of Medicine. Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC). Retrieved from https://toxtown.nlm.nih.gov/chemicals-and-contaminants/polyvinyl-chloride-pvc
- New York State Department of Health (2017, July). Bed Bugs - What They Are and How to Control Them. Retrieved from https://www.health.ny.gov/environmental/pests/bedbugs.htm
Our research
30
Mattress Protectors Considered
89
Hours of Research
2
Sleep Experts Consulted