This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission with no extra cost to you. Learn More
It’s true that there are plenty of good, comfortable mattresses that use coils for support.
But the thing is, they don’t work for everyone.
Some people don’t need that much springiness and prefer mattresses that have a slower response to applied pressure.
And that’s what we are going to look at in today’s review. We have picked the 6 best mattresses without springs to help you find the most comfortable option for your restful slumber. Also, check out our comprehensive buyer’s guide that should make shopping easier for you.
A Quick Preview
 | Best Overall – Editor’s Choice Puffy | Check Current Price Read more about this mattress |
 | Best for Combination Sleepers Loom and Leaf by Saatva | Check Current Price Read more about this mattress |
 | Best Affordable Luxury Chill Memory Foam | Check Current Price Read more about this mattress |
 | Firm Mattress Without Springs Plank Mattress | Check Current Price Read more about this mattress |
 | Best Budget Option Zoma Mattress | Check Current Price Read more about this mattress |
 | Best for Back Pain Relief Amerisleep AS3 | Check Current Price Read more about this mattress |
Our Reviews of the Best Mattresses Without Springs: Top 6 Picks
Best Overall – Editor’s Choice — Puffy
Click the button below to check current price Check Current PriceGet $750 OFF and free luxury bundle worth $600 (pillows, sheets)
Highlights
- Well-layered high-density foam top layers contours well to the body and is great for pressure relief.
- All-foam design gives impressive motion isolation.
- Cozy mattress top cover together with gel-infused breathable foam helps to sleep cool.
To lift the veil off our list of the best mattresses without springs is a top product from Puffy. The Puffy mattress is an all-foam mattress that hits that sweet spot between comfort and support. With three layers of gel-infused foam, denser cooling foam, and a high-density base, this mattress bears the sleeper’s weight and provides good support, while also offering the cradling needed for a restorative slumber. Sleeping on the Puffy mattress was a good experience, I felt relaxed with the body contouring, especially with the pressure relief around my joints; which is an indication of a quality top layer.
Read our full Puffy mattress review for more information.
Best for Combination Sleepers — Loom and Leaf by Saatva
Click the button below to check current price Check Current Price
Highlights
- specially treated cover for an antimicrobial effect, would work for allergy-prone sleepers;
- two firmness variations to satisfy more types of sleepers;
- zoned support system for proper spinal alignment.
Loom and Leaf by Saatva is the best mattress for combination sleepers without springs due to its six layers of cushioning support, giving sleepers the right amount of support with its gell-infused memory foam lumbar support layer for proper spinal alignment. It also combines three layers of memory foam with different thickness levels to engineer the hugging feel responsible for pressure relief especially during deep restorative sleep.
Best Affordable Luxury — Chill Memory Foam
Click the button below to check current price Check Current PriceSave 35% + Free Pillows & Sheets (Up to $199 Value)
Highlights
- Cooling cover for a night of easy, cool sleep.
- Motion isolation feature with conforming memory foam that is ideal for couples.
- Medium-firm density is supportive and cushioning, providing the perfect balance of comfort and support.
The Chill Memory Foam Mattress is the best affordable luxury mattress without springs due to its four layers of all-memory foam, giving sleepers the feeling of slow sinkage that’s hugging without being too much. This ‘sleeping on a cloud’ feel gives sleepers pressure relief exactly where they need it, helping sleepers wake up feeling restored and rejuvenated. It’s especially comforting for combination sleepers such as myself, who tend to change sleeping positions throughout the night — and I find I am always supported and cushioned.
On top of this, I also like how The Chill Mattress muffles motion with slow-adapting memory foam, isolating motion so it doesn’t travel across the bed as much as with other types of mattresses, such as with the Loom and Leaf by Saatva. This means that I won’t be disturbed as much if my partner is tossing and turning beside me.
Best Firm Mattress Without Springs — Plank Mattress
Click the button below to check current price Check Current Price
Highlights
- Minimal comfort layers keep your back closer to the supportive core, improving alignment.
- High-density foam core can handle the extra weight, helping keep heavier sleepers supported.
- A mix of comfort and support ensures you stay on the mattress instead of being ‘stuck.’
The Plank is my best firm mattress without springs, as it uses minimal comfort layers, a robust core, and a high amount of bounce for an all-foam mattress. Based on my tests, The Plank is a suitable choice for heavier sleepers needing more support or if you prefer firmer sleeping surfaces. Its sinkage on its Extra Firm side is only 1 inch, aligning your spine and hips with the supportive core better. The core is also made to carry more weight and pressure, which helps heavier sleepers feel supported in a mattress without springs and helps the mattress last longer.
I also found the Plank exhibits more of an ‘on top of the bed’ feeling than the Puffy as it's firmer by 1.5 inches, which can help you enjoy that freedom of movement across the bed that most hybrids and spring mattresses are known for.
What I Don’t Like About This mattress
One feature I don’t like about the Plank is that its cooling cover can feel a bit slippery due to the unique material used.
Read our full Plank mattress review for more information.
Best Budget Option — Zoma Mattress
Click the button below to check current price Check Current Price
Highlights
- The AirCloth cover is breathable and removable, helping you keep your bedding clean.
- Budget-friendly prices make this mattress a good option for those wanting an affordable mattress that doesn’t use springs.
- Responsive comfort layers help you from feeling stuck in the layers.
The Zoma is my best budget mattress without springs, as it has competitive pricing, responsive comfort layers, and a removable cover. The Zoma is priced $700 cheaper than the Puffy, $1471 cheaper than the Saatva Loom and Leaf, and $700 cheaper than the Amerisleep AS3, but it still comes with memory foam comfort layers for pressure relief, similar to these models. According to my reviews, the Zoma also comes with impressively high bounce levels due to its comfort layers, which I recorded at 8.45 inches (more than the Plank by 0.55 inches). That means you’ll be able to quickly shift sleeping positions without feeling stuck like other memory foam mattresses.
In addition, the Zoma also boasts a removable cover, similar to the Puffy, which allows you to wash and re-apply it. This helps your bed feel fresh and gives you peace of mind in case of stains or spills.
What I Don’t Like About This Mattress
One feature I don’t like about this mattress is that it may not feel supportive enough for heavier sleepers over 230 pounds due to its soft comfort layers.
Read our full Zoma mattress review for more information.
Best for Back Pain Relief — Amerisleep AS3
Click the button below to check current price Check Current Price
Highlights:
- Uses proprietary plant-based foam materials with better cushion-feel than memory foam.
- Ideal for hot sleepers as all mattress materials allow more significant airflow.
- Dense bio-foam base offers good body weight support and durability.
The AS3 by Amerisleep is a proprietary mattress crafted from Amerisleep’s Bio-Pur® foam. The bio-foam material used in the AS3 mattress feels incredibly cradling as it hugs the body when sleeping in. This allows for proper contouring and spine alignment, which is needed for back pain relief. Another advantage of the AS3 mattress is that it’s massively aerated, and therefore, it works well for hot sleepers. The bio-pur foam used in the AS3 is an open-cell material, that is, there are several tiny holes all over the material surface, through which air seeps in and keeps sleepers cool all through their sleep time.
With the soft cover and top Bio-Pur® layer of the mattress, the AS3 feels really cozy when sleeping in. More so, it comes in the medium plush firmness level, which means the foam is more accommodating. And just below the outer layers, you can also feel a more steady foam layer which offers more pressure-point cushioning. Then, there’s the base layer which acts as the core support to carry the sleeper's weight. However, weightier sleepers might find the foam too plush and less supportive.
Read our full Amerisleep AS3 mattress review for more information.
What Options Do We Have When It Comes to Mattresses Without Springs? + Their Peculiarities
There’s a lot to choose from among coil-less mattresses, but to make the right choice, you need to understand the main differences between the mattress types. That’s how you can decide which non-spring mattress would work for you the best. So, here are the main options that you have:
- Memory foam. These mattresses are made using visco-elastic foam that can contour and adapt to one’s body. This promotes even weight distribution (1) and can help with pressure alleviation. Additionally, memory foam has a slow response to applied pressure, so this material is very common among the mattresses with the best motion isolation that work great for partnered sleep. A word of warning, though: memory foam tends to trap body heat and can make users sleep hot. If you want a cooling effect, go with models that use gel infusion or an open-cell construction. Also, keep in mind that most memory foam mattresses have weak edges. This might be an issue for couples who require more space.
- Polyfoam. Polyfoam is a bit more resilient than memory foam and has a slightly faster response to pressure. That’s why polyfoam mattresses often feel less restricting while still being able to envelop the body and provide tension relief. Additionally, polyfoam is typically cheaper. Nonetheless, there are plenty of quality options available on the market, even among safer mattresses without fiberglass. So, getting a polyfoam mattress doesn’t mean that you will settle for something cheaper and of lower quality. If you choose denser foams and buy from a reliable company, it would simply mean that your mattress will have a slightly different feel than memory foam models.
- Latex. Another popular option among the non-spring mattresses is latex. Latex has a rather unique feel and might not be everyone’s cup of tea. It’s resilient and somewhat springy. At the same time, latex can cradle the body gently and might aid proper weight distribution. Therefore, a latex mattress could be kind of like a middle ground between overly bouncy coils and hugging foam. Furthermore, latex doesn’t sleep hot. It’s also worth mentioning that latex models belong to the most long-lasting mattresses that have an impressive lifespan. That’s one of the reasons why latex mattresses tend to be quite pricey. However, keep in mind that most latex mattresses have weak edges.
- Air mattress. Now, air mattresses aren’t that popular for everyday use, but some sleepers appreciate their adjustability. With an air mattress, you can achieve your ideal firmness level by simply deflating or inflating your airbed. However, it’s important to understand that these mattresses aren’t always as comfortable due to their construction and may not deliver enough pressure relief. Plus, they have a relatively short lifespan.
How to Pick the Proper Firmness of Your New Mattress Without Springs
Now, firmness is an aspect that can often be overlooked by shoppers. And that’s how one can easily end up with back pain and poor sleep. You see, if you pick a coil-less mattress that’s either too soft or too firm for you, your spine will fall into misalignment during the night. This can lead to too much strain on some of its parts and, consequently, back pain. Therefore, it’s crucial to pick the mattress firmness that could help you maintain a healthy, comfortable spinal alignment during the night (2). And optimal firmness level is different for different types of sleepers:
- Side sleepers. Because this sleep position can result in pressure points, side sleepers are recommended to choose softer mattresses. They need enough of the sinkage for their hips and shoulders, which a softer mattress can offer.
- Back sleepers. Back sleepers need to remain in a relatively straight line during the night, that’s why they don’t require that much sinkage. Back sleepers usually feel the most comfortable sleeping on medium and medium-firm mattresses.
- Stomach sleepers. For stomach sleepers, support is crucial (otherwise they can sink in and put too much tension on the lower back). That’s why stomach sleepers are usually advised to pick firm mattresses.
- Combo sleepers. Combination sleepers tend to switch positions frequently during the night, so their mattress shouldn’t restrict movement. In most cases, medium and medium-firm mattresses work the best for this sleep position. They can deliver proper support and just enough cushioning without making it hard for sleepers to change positions.
Other Criteria to Account for When Shopping for a Good Mattress Without Springs
Once you’ve figured out what mattress type and firmness level would be the most suitable for your specific needs, you can consider some extra factors that can potentially help you make the wisest choice. They include:
- Budget. The first thing you might want to do when shopping is setting a certain budget you are willing to allocate for your new mattress. This little trick can help you achieve two things. First, you will be less likely to overspend. Second, by determining how much you are ready to spend, you can easily narrow down the list of available options. Consequently, it should be much easier for you to pick one.
- Thermoregulation. Spring mattresses are super breathable and don’t sleep hot. If you want the same effect but prefer non-spring models, look for mattresses that could help with thermoregulation during the night. For example, latex is naturally neutral in terms of temperature. If you are considering foam, remember that gel-infused and open-cell models are less likely to make you overheat.
- Edge support. Again, most coil-free mattresses have weak edges. It can be an issue if you enjoy sleeping near the edge or simply want more space. If that’s the case, you might have to turn to firmer models (if your sleep position allows for it), as they usually have stronger edges.
- Warranty. The duration of the warranty period can be a sign of how much trust the manufacturer puts in their product. The longer the warranty, the calmer you can feel concerning the quality of your mattress. After all, the warranty period is your protection as a customer, so it wouldn’t hurt picking among more long-lasting options.
- Sleep trial. An in-home sleep trial can give you a chance to return your mattress in case it doesn’t feel comfortable enough. However, keep in mind that most manufacturers include a mandatory break-in period that typically lasts for at least 14 days. During this period, you cannot return your mattress. It’s pretty common for most mattress companies, as most non-coil models require some time to adjust to your body. Plus, you might also need a few days to get used to your new mattress.
- Bed frame compatibility. If your bed frame has slats, the spacing between them might not be suitable for all non-spring mattresses. So, you should definitely check the recommendations on the mattress page. The thing is, if your slats are too far apart, your foam (or latex) mattress might not receive the needed support. This somewhat squishy material can sag through the spaces between slats and may develop indentations. Naturally, you won’t be likely to sleep well on a saggy mattress, so it’s best to prevent such situations by checking the bed frame compatibility.
If you are still feeling hesitant, you can consider a few more comfortable mattresses. Check out here to find that perfect model for your restful slumber.
F.A.Q.
Which mattress type is better – springs or foam?
It would depend on your personal preferences. Foam mattresses typically provide better pressure relief, while spring models offer bouncier support, breathability, and stronger edges.
How long does a non-spring mattress last?
On average, foam mattresses last for up to 10-15 years. Latex models are more durable, with a lifespan of around 15-20 years. Air mattresses are the least durable ones and typically last for up to 5 years.
What are the benefits of spring-free mattresses?
The biggest benefits of sleeping on a spring-free mattress are improved pressure relief and better motion isolation.
Can a mattress without springs be firm?
Yes, you can find plenty of firm mattresses that don’t use springs in their construction. Instead, they use denser foam or latex.
Are there non-spring mattresses that have strong edges?
Yes, but most of them belong to the firmer category.
Summary
If you don’t like bouncy coils, it doesn’t mean that you have to feel limited when trying to choose a new mattress. Luckily, there are plenty of cool non-coil options to choose from.
On your quest to find the best mattress that doesn’t have coils, don’t forget to account for your favorite sleeping position and choose the firmness level accordingly. Plus, check the warranty coverage conditions and whether your current bed frame is suited for the mattress you are considering (just to be on the safe side).
For readers who need our top recommendation, the Puffy mattress comes as our recommended choice for mattresses without springs. Our choice boils down to the design of the mattress and the quality of the product. It uses multiple foam layers for effective pressure point relief, and then combines a well-seamed mattress cover and a high-density core to provide enough body weight support for a healthy sleep life.
Why do you prefer non-spring mattresses? And have you picked your favorite model from this list? Let us know in the comments!
References:
- Annie Stuart (February 08, 2010). Memory Foam: Pros and Cons. Retrieved from https://www.webmd.com/sleep-disorders/features/memory-foam-pros-and-cons
- Robert S. Griffin (December 11, 2020). 5 Things You Should Know about Sleep and Low Back Pain. Retrieved from https://www.hss.edu/article_sleep-and-low-back-pain.asp
Our research
27
Mattresses Considered
112
Hours of Research
2
Sleep Experts Consulted
I am looking for a firm mattress,
I sleep only on my back .I have hardware top to bottom on my spine.the mattress I bought 4 yrs ago is so caved in it hurts to sleep on it.