Best Mattresses for Big and Tall Guys: Top Picks to Make You Sleep Like a Baby

Last updated May 30, 2020 Read 21 min
Written by: Alex Savy

Being big just means there’s more of you to love, and that’s a fact.

One more fact: you need to consider your weight when picking a suitable bed.

After all, we all want to sleep like a baby. And how could that be possible if your mattress sags or flattens after a few months?

Today, I’ve prepared a review of the best mattresses for big and tall guys that could help you make just the right choice.

A Quick Preview

Winkbeds Plus
Best Overall

WinkBed Plus
Shop Now on WinkBeds.com
Read more about this mattress
Amerisleep AS3
Best for Heavy Side Sleepers

Amerisleep AS3
Shop Now on Amerisleep.com
Read more about this mattress
Botanical Bliss by Plushbeds
Best for Cooler Sleep

Botanical Bliss by Plushbeds
Shop Now on PlushBeds.com
Read more about this mattress
Idle Hybrid
Best Bouncy Support

Idle Hybrid
Shop Now on IdleSleep.com
Read more about this mattress
Puffy
Best Budget Pick

Puffy
Shop Now on Puffy.com
Read more about this mattress

Our Reviews of the Best Mattresses for Big and Tall Guys

Best Overall – Editor’s Choice - WinkBed Plus

Winkbed

Click on the button below to check price Check current price Read our detailed review Shop Now on WinkBeds.com

Highlights

  • hybrid construction;
  • breathable Tencel cover;
  • sewn-in pillow-top.

I want to start my review of the best mattresses for big and tall guys with the WinkBed Plus. This model has everything you might wish for and effectively combines versatile materials for improved support, pressure relief, and thermoregulation.

Now, as this is a hybrid mattress, it belongs to the more expensive category. However, you get what you pay for. The WinkBed Plus is well-made and durable. It feels solid and sturdy, which is perfect for heavier sleepers. This model rates around 7.5 on the firmness scale (with 10 being the firmest) if you weigh less than 300 pounds and 6-6.5 out of 10 if you are larger than that.

The WinkBed Plus uses a combination of pocketed coils and foam Euro-top. The coils feature a zoned support system, which offers slightly different firmness levels for separate parts of your body, adjusting to the pressure differences. The edges are reinforced with extra coils for more stability. As for the Euro-top, it uses gel-infused foam for cooling and a layer of latex for bouncier pressure relief.

The WinkBed Plus is an excellent example of a mattress that is suitable for larger and taller guys. It is supportive, durable, and most importantly, reliable.

Best for Heavy Side Sleepers - Amerisleep AS3

Amerisleep AS3

Click on the button below to check price Check current price Read our detailed review Shop Now on Amerisleep.com

Highlights

  • foam construction;
  • medium feel;
  • zoned layer for pinpoint support.

The next contestant for the right to be in this review of the best mattresses for big and tall guys is the AS3 by Amerisleep. This model stands out from the competitors thanks to the targeted pressure relief it provides, which results in high comfort levels.

Here’s the deal:

This is a medium mattress, which means it would be perfect for heavier side sleepers. Back and stomach sleepers might find it too soft, especially if they weigh more than 230 pounds. The AS3 allows for a decent amount of sinkage and nicely cradles hips and shoulders. 

It gets better:

The second polyfoam comfort layer features a proprietary design and offers different support levels for your head, shoulders, back, hips, and legs. This results in a very balanced feel, which so many other foam mattresses fail to provide for heavier users.

The AS3 proves that a good bed for heavier and taller people shouldn’t be as firm as a brick. This mattress offers a winning combination of support and pressure relief, which so many users would appreciate.

Best for Cooler Sleep - Botanical Bliss by Plushbeds

Botanical Bliss by Plushbeds

Click on the button below to check price and go shopping

Check current price Read our detailed review Shop Now on PlushBeds.com

Highlights

  • two firmness options;
  • all-latex design (organic Dunlop);
  • cotton cover;
  • 3 thickness options.

The next item I want to mention in my review is this latex bed by Plushbeds. This is a great mattress for a tall person or a heavier sleeper due to many factors. It is sturdy, reliable, and supportive. But its key advantage is that it can make you sleep cool.

Now, the Botanical Bliss uses high-quality materials. The cover is made of breathable cotton, which is soft to the touch and safe for your skin. The next layer is organic wool, which contributes to cushioning and temperature regulation. Next, we have 3 layers of Dunlop latex, with each one having a different density. This makes the mattress feel supportive, bouncy, and easy to move around on.

Here’s the best part:

As this model comes in 2 firmness options and also lets you choose among 3 thickness levels, there’s an option for almost any user. The Medium model rates around 5.5 on the firmness scale. However, for tall and heavier sleepers, I would recommend the Medium-Firm option, which is 6.5 out of 10.

This organic, breathable mattress was made to impress. The Botanical Bliss offers bouncy support and blissfully cool sleep. Plus, it gives you a wide choice, which is a nice bonus.

Best Bouncy Support - Idle HybridIdle Hybrid

Click on the button below to check price and go shopping

Check current price Read our detailed review Shop Now on IdleSleep.com

Highlights

  • 2 firmness options;
  • dual-sided firmness available;
  • flippable hybrid.

A good bounce is important for larger users. That’s why I’m including the Botanical Bliss in my review of the best mattresses for big and tall guys. This organic mattress won’t let you feel trapped when sleeping. And it can do much more than that.

Now, the Idle Hybris is a flippable mattress. This means it will serve you longer. Flipping it from time to time will prevent premature sagging, helping you preserve the supportive properties. Another cool thing is that the Idle comes in 2 firmness options, with Luxury Firm being more suitable for heavier guys.

The manufacturer uses a combination of pocketed coils and foam. There are 3 layers of foam, with each being a proprietary material and having slightly different characteristics. Also, the Idle has a faster response than memory foam beds but offers a good deal of contouring and close conforming.

Overall, this is a great mattress that has a good chance of transforming your sleep. Being a hybrid bed, the Idle delivers a very balanced feel and features an anti-sagging design.

Best Budget Pick - Puffy

Puffy Mattress

Click on the button below to check price and go shopping

Check current price Read our detailed review Shop Now on Puffy.com

Highlights

  • all-foam mattress;
  • medium feel;
  • gel-infused for lower heat retention.

Now, meet the Puffy, last but not least. This foam mattress is very reasonably priced (and currently on sale!), but the list of its pros doesn’t end here. This mattress excels at providing superb pressure relief and can make you feel like sleeping on a cloud.

The Puffy uses polyfoam for the base and the transition layer, plus gel-infused memory foam for the comfort layer. This is a medium mattress that rates around 5 on the firmness scale. It offers a generous hug for your pressure points and does a great job of relieving tension. Plus, despite being a bit softer than other mattresses I’ve reviewed, it can easily support larger weights without sinking too deep and starting to sag too soon.

Another thing worth mentioning is the Puffy’s motion absorption properties. This mattress has a rather slow response, so it doesn’t allow motion transfer. Good news for couples who tend to wake each other up by tossing and turning during the night!

If you are looking for an affordable but sturdy foam mattress, look no more! The Puffy works to deliver a soft cushion for your pressure points and can make you feel like sleeping on a cloud, at the same time keeping your spine properly aligned.

How Different Mattress Materials Work for Larger Sleepers

How Different Mattress Materials Work for Larger Sleepers

When looking for suitable mattresses for big guys, you need to remember that materials matter. One bed can be perfect for some users and feel like a saggy piece of sponge to others.

Don’t worry, though: 

Learning about mattress materials isn’t such a big deal. It will take you minutes but will help you figure out what you need

Now, when it comes to top-rated beds for heavy people and tall users, we have the following options:

  • Foam. Being one of the most popular options, foam mattresses offer close conforming, slow response, and great pressure relief. And yes, some firm models are suitable for larger individuals, especially those made with polyfoam. However, you need to check the foam density. It’s measured in PCF, or pounds per cubic foot. If we’re talking about memory foam, anything below 4 PCF would not be enough for users over 230 pounds. As for polyfoam (which is a bit bouncier and offers a faster response), anything higher than 1.7 PCF could make a good mattress for a large person.
  • Innerspring. Such beds offer good levels of support, bounciness, and strong edges. However, the exact properties will depend on the quality and thickness (or gauge) of the coils. Typically, the thickest gauge is 12, while the thinnest is 18. You can choose the suitable thickness and firmness level according to your sleeping position (which we will discuss later) and the manufacturer’s recommendations. What makes innerspring mattresses a great option for larger users is the excellent thermoregulation they can ensure. The coil system allows for effective air circulation, which means you won’t sleep hot on an innerspring bed. However, keep in mind that such mattresses tend to have a shorter lifespan. So, if you don’t mind changing your bed after 5 or 6 years, you can give an innerspring mattress a try.
  • Latex. Such mattresses also come in different firmness levels and density options, which makes them suitable for heavier users. They are preferred by hot sleepers and eco-enthusiasts. Another cool thing about latex is its durability. Such beds don’t sag that fast and can hold up for 15 years on average. However, keep in mind that such mattresses belong to the more expensive category.
  • Hybrid. Hybrid mattresses typically combine a coil base and foam comfort layers. There are also coil + latex options available. What makes them great mattresses for larger persons is the multiple configurations of layers that result in extra thickness. Additionally, hybrid beds combine stable, dense support with a moderate amount of cradling, which is optimal for heavier sleepers. Such beds also offer good air circulation and strong edges. As for the disadvantages, hybrid beds tend to be among more expensive ones and may have shorter lifespans if they use solid spring units rather than individual coils.

“If both you and your partner are larger than average, it may be challenging to find a good mattress that would suit you both. Keep in mind that foam is the best option for motion isolation. However, for heavier users, it is recommended to consider polyfoam or latex since these materials offer a faster response.”

Picking a Suitable Mattress Firmness for Your Sleeping Position

When trying to find a top-quality bed for heavy people, the rules change a bit.

I mean, it’s easy-breezy for average users. But if you’re a bit extra, the general rules do not always apply, especially when we’re talking about choosing the correct firmness level.

So, here are some specific tips for each sleeping position:

  • Side sleepers. This is the most popular position that requires a good amount of cushioning for the protruding parts of your body. Now, a good mattress for big guys who sleep on their side should be medium to medium-firm. This level should provide a good amount of support while still offering cushioning and pressure relief.
  • Back sleepers. If you are a back sleeper, you may want to consider a firm mattress that would rate around 8 on the firmness scale. When sleeping on your back, you need a moderate amount of sinkage (mainly for your hips) and a good level of support to keep the spine properly aligned throughout the night. To contribute to that, consider using a flat pillow that would not hold your head up.
  • Stomach sleepers. This position may let your stomach sink deep into the mattress, which would create an unnatural curve in the spine. This can be dangerous for your health and may cause back pain. Therefore, there’s no need for extra cushioning or cradling for this sleeping position. Good mattresses for big guys who sleep on their stomach should be firm or even extra-firm

“Sometimes, even the best mattress might not perform well when the foundation isn’t good enough. After all, it contributes to the overall support level. So, if yours is too old or weak, you may want to consider replacing it with a new one. Keep in mind that manufacturers’ recommendations aren’t just suggestions. They know what support their mattress needs.”

What to Consider When Searching for the Best Mattress for Big and Tall Guys

Now, we all have different ideas of the “best”.

After all, as the old saying goes, tastes differ. 

Still, when shopping for a top-notch bed for heavy people, you might want to consider the general factors that make a good bed (I mean, aside from type and firmness). Just to give you an idea of what to look for:

  • Thickness. When looking for the best mattress for big and tall guys, you need to remember that heavier sleepers put more pressure on their beds, which creates more compression. In this case, the rule of thumb is the thicker your bed is, the better. Now, foam models tend to be thinner than hybrids and innerspring beds, but this may vary depending on the manufacturer. In general, a suitable mattress for heavier people should be at least 12 inches thick.
  • Size. This aspect is essential when it comes to picking a mattress for a tall person. Now, here’s the deal: most common mattress sizes have similar lengths. For instance, Full measures 75 inches while Queen and King are 80 inches long. That might not be enough for taller individuals. In this case, you may want to consider a Cal King, which is 84 inches long. 
  • Cooling. Sleeping hot is a common issue for many heavier users. Higher body mass results in more heat production. Plus, you sink in deeper, which can make your mattress trap heat more. Especially if we’re talking about foam beds, which are known for their mediocre thermoregulation. However, if the manufacturer uses cooling gel in the top layers, this may help you stay cool. An even better option would be a latex or a hybrid mattress. Such models offer unobstructed air circulation that results in excellent thermoregulation.
  • Edge support. Now, if you share your bed with a loved one or tend to roll to the edge during the night, your mattress has to offer great edge support. So, consider a mattress with coils. Foam and latex usually allow more compression around the perimeter, which can work great for solo sleepers or those who don’t move a lot during the night.

If both you and your partner are above average, you may need an extra-firm mattress that would provide enough support for your combined weight. If only one of you weighs more than 230 pounds, a good firm mattress should be enough. However, keep in mind that your bed may start sagging more under a heavier user. That’s why it’s advised to rotate your mattress regularly.”

Conclusion

Looking for the right mattress may seem like a challenge at first. Hopefully, this review made you one step closer towards getting your dream bed. After all, now you know at least 5 awesome options to choose from. To me, however, the absolute champion is the WinkBed Plus. This mattress will not disappoint you. It uses top-notch materials and combines them effectively to deliver great support, pressure relief, cooling, and durability. To me, that sounds like a perfect match! What do you think? Which one is your personal favorite? Let me know in the comments below!

Our research

35

Mattresses Considered

156

Hours of Research

3

Sleep Experts Consulted

Subscribe to get updates and new deals!

Zero spam. Unsubscribe at any time

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission with no extra cost to you. Learn More

Leave a comment